Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, Saint Louis University, St. Louis, MO 63108, USA.
Sensors (Basel). 2019 Mar 14;19(6):1284. doi: 10.3390/s19061284.
Urban areas feature complex and heterogeneous land covers which create challenging issues for tree species classification. The increased availability of high spatial resolution multispectral satellite imagery and LiDAR datasets combined with the recent evolution of deep learning within remote sensing for object detection and scene classification, provide promising opportunities to map individual tree species with greater accuracy and resolution. However, there are knowledge gaps that are related to the contribution of Worldview-3 SWIR bands, very high resolution PAN band and LiDAR data in detailed tree species mapping. Additionally, contemporary deep learning methods are hampered by lack of training samples and difficulties of preparing training data. The objective of this study was to examine the potential of a novel deep learning method, Dense Convolutional Network (DenseNet), to identify dominant individual tree species in a complex urban environment within a fused image of WorldView-2 VNIR, Worldview-3 SWIR and LiDAR datasets. DenseNet results were compared against two popular machine classifiers in remote sensing image analysis, Random Forest (RF) and Support Vector Machine (SVM). Our results demonstrated that: (1) utilizing a data fusion approach beginning with VNIR and adding SWIR, LiDAR, and panchromatic (PAN) bands increased the overall accuracy of the DenseNet classifier from 75.9% to 76.8%, 81.1% and 82.6%, respectively. (2) DenseNet significantly outperformed RF and SVM for the classification of eight dominant tree species with an overall accuracy of 82.6%, compared to 51.8% and 52% for SVM and RF classifiers, respectively. (3) DenseNet maintained superior performance over RF and SVM classifiers under restricted training sample quantities which is a major limiting factor for deep learning techniques. Overall, the study reveals that DenseNet is more effective for urban tree species classification as it outperforms the popular RF and SVM techniques when working with highly complex image scenes regardless of training sample size.
城市地区具有复杂多样的土地覆盖类型,这给树种分类带来了挑战。高空间分辨率多光谱卫星图像和 LiDAR 数据集的可用性不断提高,以及遥感中目标检测和场景分类领域深度学习的最新发展,为更准确、更精细地绘制单个树种提供了有前景的机会。然而,仍存在一些知识空白,这些空白与 Worldview-3 SWIR 波段、超高分辨率 PAN 波段和 LiDAR 数据在详细树种制图中的贡献有关。此外,当代深度学习方法受到训练样本缺乏和训练数据准备困难的限制。本研究的目的是检验一种新的深度学习方法——密集卷积网络(DenseNet)在融合 Worldview-2 VNIR、Worldview-3 SWIR 和 LiDAR 数据集的图像中识别复杂城市环境下主要单木树种的潜力。DenseNet 的结果与遥感图像分析中两种流行的机器分类器(随机森林(RF)和支持向量机(SVM))进行了比较。我们的结果表明:(1)利用从 VNIR 开始并添加 SWIR、LiDAR 和全色(PAN)波段的数据融合方法,DenseNet 分类器的整体精度从 75.9%分别提高到 76.8%、81.1%和 82.6%。(2)DenseNet 对 8 种主要树种的分类明显优于 RF 和 SVM,整体精度为 82.6%,而 SVM 和 RF 分类器的精度分别为 51.8%和 52%。(3)在训练样本数量有限的情况下,DenseNet 比 RF 和 SVM 分类器的性能更为优越,这是深度学习技术的一个主要限制因素。总体而言,本研究表明,DenseNet 在城市树种分类方面更为有效,因为它在处理高度复杂的图像场景时,无论是在训练样本数量方面,都优于流行的 RF 和 SVM 技术。