Department of Neurosciences, Reproductive and Odontostomatological Sciences, Federico II University of Naples, Naples, Italy.
D.eb.RA. Mexico Foundation, Monterrey, Mexico.
J Oral Rehabil. 2019 Jul;46(7):657-665. doi: 10.1111/joor.12796. Epub 2019 Apr 11.
The aim of this review was to investigate quality assessment and quantitative information on burning mouth syndrome (BMS) on YouTube™ videos.
An electronic search of YouTube™ videos on BMS was performed using subject headings, keywords and synonyms of BMS. For each video, quality information, via the quality assessment score (QAS) and quantitative information, such as the total number of results per term searched, date of upload, clip length, view count, source category (professional, personal, educational, mixed), number of likes and dislikes and YouTube™ category were evaluated.
The search identified 3768 videos of which only 114 were included in our analysis: the quality of videos was very poor (mean ± standard deviation = 1.76 ± 1.64). The most representative categories were "educational" with 53 (46.5%) videos scoring between 0 and 4 and "mixed" with 24 (21.1%) videos scoring between 0 and 2. Significant differences were found among all four categories in relation to length in seconds (P < 0.001), number of views (P = 0.006) and interaction index (P = 0.001), as well as between "professional" and the other categories and between "educational" and "personal" in relation to length in seconds (P < 0.001), between "educational" and "personal" (P < 0.001) and "personal" and "mixed" category in relation to interaction index (P = 0.003) and between "professional" and "personal" in relation to views per day (P = 0.015).
A large number of videos regarding BMS have published on YouTube™, with a wide range of distribution regarding their length and views. Unfortunately, they presented unreliable information which is most often scientifically inaccurate. Health care institutions and professionals should be more actively involved in improving high-quality e-information about BMS on YouTube™.
本研究旨在调查 YouTube 上有关灼口综合征(BMS)的视频的质量评估和定量信息。
使用 BMS 的主题词、关键词和同义词对 YouTube 上的 BMS 视频进行电子检索。对每个视频的质量信息(通过质量评估得分(QAS))和定量信息(如搜索词的总结果数、上传日期、视频长度、观看次数、来源类别(专业、个人、教育、混合)、点赞和不喜欢的数量以及 YouTube 类别)进行评估。
搜索共确定了 3768 个视频,但只有 114 个视频被纳入我们的分析:视频质量非常差(平均值 ± 标准差=1.76±1.64)。最具代表性的类别是“教育”,其中 53 个(46.5%)视频的得分在 0 到 4 之间,“混合”类别有 24 个(21.1%)视频的得分在 0 到 2 之间。在所有四个类别中,视频长度(秒)(P<0.001)、观看次数(P=0.006)和交互指数(P=0.001)存在显著差异,以及“专业”与其他类别之间、“教育”与“个人”之间在视频长度(秒)(P<0.001)、“教育”与“个人”(P<0.001)和“个人”与“混合”类别之间的交互指数(P=0.003)以及“专业”与“个人”之间在每日观看次数(P=0.015)方面存在显著差异。
大量关于 BMS 的视频在 YouTube 上发布,其长度和观看次数分布广泛。不幸的是,这些视频提供了不可靠的信息,这些信息往往在科学上是不准确的。医疗机构和专业人员应更积极地参与改善 YouTube 上有关 BMS 的高质量电子信息。