Harrison Leila E, White Bobbie Ann A, Hawrylak Kaitlyn, McIntosh David
Office of Admissions, Recruitment, and Inclusion, Washington State University Elson S. Floyd College of MedicineSpokaneWashington.
Department of Humanities in Medicine, Texas A&M College of MedicineTempleTexas.
Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent). 2019 Jan 15;32(1):50-53. doi: 10.1080/08998280.2018.1519519. eCollection 2019 Jan.
The aim of this study was to analyze themes related to explicit bias in patient-doctor relationships among fourth-year medical students. Class cohorts between 2013 and 2016 taking an online elective, "Self and Culture," submitted reflections about explicit bias. Thematic analysis was conducted on 283 student submissions totaling 849 entries until saturation. Themes included explicit bias toward patients with obesity, those who smoked, those from low-socioeconomic conditions, and, to a lesser extent, race/ethnicity. Themes related to the patient-doctor relationship included a negative impact on the relationship itself, trust, treatment of the patient, and patient experience. Themes related to making a positive impact included seeking positive treatment of the patient, understanding patients' circumstances rather than making assumptions, partnering with the patient, and education. Furthermore, researchers noted external versus internal attribution of the bias. Some students used neutral language to explain explicit biases, whereas fewer used internal attribution language. Results demonstrated that this type of reflection promoted personal insight, and faculty members should be trained to ensure successful crucial conversations about the impact of assumptions and biases on patient treatment, care plans, and health disparities. Finally, the curriculum should be intentional, providing experiences with marginalized populations to develop cultural humility and empathy.
本研究的目的是分析与四年级医学生医患关系中显性偏见相关的主题。2013年至2016年间参加在线选修课“自我与文化”的班级群组提交了关于显性偏见的反思。对283份学生提交的总计849条记录进行了主题分析,直至饱和。主题包括对肥胖患者、吸烟者、社会经济条件差的患者以及在较小程度上对种族/族裔的显性偏见。与医患关系相关的主题包括对关系本身、信任、患者治疗和患者体验的负面影响。与产生积极影响相关的主题包括寻求对患者的积极治疗、理解患者的情况而非做出假设、与患者合作以及教育。此外,研究人员指出了偏见的外部归因与内部归因。一些学生使用中性语言来解释显性偏见,而使用内部归因语言的学生较少。结果表明,这种反思促进了个人洞察力,教师应接受培训,以确保就假设和偏见对患者治疗、护理计划和健康差距的影响进行成功的关键对话。最后,课程应该是有目的的,提供与边缘化人群的接触机会,以培养文化谦逊和同理心。