Penders G E M, van Nispen Tot Pannerden A, van Loenen G, van de Vathorst S, van der Heijden F M M A
Tijdschr Psychiatr. 2019;61(4):248-256.
In the Netherlands there is an increasing amount of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (eas) for patients with psychiatric illnesses. However, in recent years, psychiatrists have become more reluctant to assist with or apply eas. In 1995, 47% of psychiatrists were prepared to grant a request for eas, compared with 37% in 2016. In the literature various personal, medical and ethical arguments are mentioned for reluctance or willingness regarding eas.
AIM: To determine the point of view of residents in psychiatry about requests for eas, to gain insight into their arguments for being reluctant or willing regarding eas, and to determine their opinion on attention paid to eas during the medical training of a psychiatrist.
METHOD: A survey on eas was developed based on a literature study. Residents in psychiatry from the consortium Zuid-Nederland-Noord (znn) (n=78) were asked to complete this survey online.
RESULTS: A total of 37 residents (47%) responded. Of these, most residents (73%) found it conceivable that they would grant a request for eas from a patient with psychiatric illness. Residents did not agree with the classical arguments for reluctance. The training of psychiatrists paid insufficient structural attention to eas.
CONCLUSION: This study shows that a majority of Dutch residents in psychiatry find it conceivable that they would grant a request for eas. According to these residents, more attention is warranted on eas in the medical training to psychiatrist.
在荷兰,患有精神疾病的患者接受安乐死和医生协助自杀(EAS)的案例数量不断增加。然而,近年来,精神科医生越来越不愿意协助实施或应用EAS。1995年,47%的精神科医生准备同意EAS请求,而在2016年这一比例为37%。文献中提到了各种关于对EAS持不情愿或愿意态度的个人、医学和伦理方面的论据。
确定精神科住院医生对EAS请求的观点,深入了解他们对EAS持不情愿或愿意态度的论据,并确定他们对精神科医生医学培训中对EAS关注情况的看法。
在文献研究的基础上开发了一项关于EAS的调查。来自南荷兰-北荷兰联盟(ZNN)(n = 78)的精神科住院医生被要求在线完成这项调查。
共有37名住院医生(47%)做出回应。其中,大多数住院医生(73%)认为他们有可能同意患有精神疾病的患者提出的EAS请求。住院医生不同意那些不情愿的经典论据。精神科医生的培训在结构上对EAS的关注不足。
这项研究表明,大多数荷兰精神科住院医生认为他们有可能同意EAS请求。据这些住院医生称,在精神科医生的医学培训中,有必要对EAS给予更多关注。