Nazari Atiye, Alavimajd Hamid, Shakeri Nezhat, Bakhshandeh Mohsen, Faghihzadeh Elham, Marzbani Hengameh
Department of Biostatistics, Faculty of Allied Medical Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Radiology Technology, Faculty of Allied Medical Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Basic Clin Neurosci. 2019 Mar-Apr;10(2):147-156. doi: 10.32598/bcn.9.10.140. Epub 2019 Mar 1.
In recent years, brain functional connectivity studies are extended using the advanced statistical methods. Functional connectivity is identified by synchronous activation in a spatially distinct region of the brain in resting-state functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) data. For this purpose there are several methods such as seed-based correlation analysis based on temporal correlation between different Regions of Interests (ROIs) or between brain's voxels of prior seed.
In the current study, test-retest Resting State functional MRI (rs-fMRI) data of 21 healthy subjects were analyzed to predict second replication connectivity map using first replication data. A potential estimator is "raw estimator" that uses the first replication data from each subject to predict the second replication connectivity map of the same subject. The second estimator, "mean estimator" uses the average of all sample subjects' connectivity to estimate the correlation map. Shrinkage estimator is made by shrinking raw estimator towards the average connectivity map of all subjects' first replicate. Prediction performance of the second replication correlation map is evaluated by Mean Squared Error (MSE) criteria.
By the employment of seed-based correlation analysis and choosing precentral gyrus as the ROI over 21 subjects in the study, on average MSE for raw, mean and shrinkage estimator were 0.2169, 0.1118, and 0.1103, respectively. Also, percent reduction of MSE for shrinkage and mean estimator in comparison with raw estimator is 49.14 and 48.45, respectively.
Shrinkage approach has the positive effect on the prediction of functional connectivity. When data has a large between session variability, prediction of connectivity map can be improved by shrinking towards population mean.
近年来,脑功能连接性研究通过先进的统计方法得以扩展。功能连接性是通过静息态功能磁共振成像(MRI)数据中大脑空间上不同区域的同步激活来识别的。为此,有几种方法,例如基于不同感兴趣区域(ROI)之间或先前种子脑体素之间的时间相关性的基于种子的相关分析。
在当前研究中,分析了21名健康受试者的重测静息态功能MRI(rs-fMRI)数据,以使用第一次重复数据预测第二次重复连接图。一种潜在的估计器是“原始估计器”,它使用每个受试者的第一次重复数据来预测同一受试者的第二次重复连接图。第二种估计器“均值估计器”使用所有样本受试者连接性的平均值来估计相关图。收缩估计器是通过将原始估计器向所有受试者第一次重复的平均连接图收缩而制成的。通过均方误差(MSE)标准评估第二次重复相关图的预测性能。
通过采用基于种子的相关分析并选择中央前回作为研究中21名受试者的ROI,原始、均值和收缩估计器的平均MSE分别为0.2169、0.1118和0.1103。此外,与原始估计器相比,收缩估计器和均值估计器的MSE降低百分比分别为49.14和48.45。
收缩方法对功能连接性的预测有积极影响。当数据在不同会话之间具有较大变异性时,通过向总体均值收缩可以改善连接图的预测。