Mañago Mark M, Glick Stephanie, Hebert Jeffrey R, Coote Susan, Schenkman Margaret
Int J MS Care. 2019 Mar-Apr;21(2):47-56. doi: 10.7224/1537-2073.2017-079.
There are mixed reports on the effectiveness of strength training to improve gait performance in people with multiple sclerosis (MS), yet the reasons for these inconsistent results are not clear. Therefore, a critical review was conducted to explore dosage, frequency, mode, position, and muscle targets of studies that have included strength training in people with MS.
An electronic search was conducted through July 2017. Randomized controlled trials involving people with MS were included that implemented strength training with or without other interventions and assessed 1) strength in the lower extremities and/or trunk and 2) gait speed and/or endurance. Strength and gait results were extracted, along with exercise frequency, intensity, duration, mode, position, and muscle targets.
Thirteen trials met the inclusion criteria; nine used dosing consistent with recommended guidelines. Overall, six studies reported significant between-group strength improvements, and four reported within-group changes. Four studies reported significant between-group gait improvements for gait speed and/or endurance, and two reported within-group changes. Most exercises were performed on exercise machines while sitting, supine, or prone. The most common intervention target was knee extension.
Studies generally improved strength, yet only two studies reported potentially meaningful between-group changes in gait. Future strength intervention studies designed to improve gait might consider dosing beyond that of the minimum intensity to improve strength and explore muscles targets, positions, and modes that are task-specific to walking.
关于力量训练对改善多发性硬化症(MS)患者步态表现的有效性,存在多种不同的报道,然而这些结果不一致的原因尚不清楚。因此,进行了一项批判性综述,以探讨在MS患者中纳入力量训练的研究的剂量、频率、模式、姿势和肌肉目标。
截至2017年7月进行了电子检索。纳入了涉及MS患者的随机对照试验,这些试验实施了有或无其他干预措施的力量训练,并评估了1)下肢和/或躯干的力量,以及2)步态速度和/或耐力。提取了力量和步态结果,以及运动频率、强度、持续时间、模式、姿势和肌肉目标。
13项试验符合纳入标准;9项试验的剂量符合推荐指南。总体而言,6项研究报告了组间力量有显著改善,4项研究报告了组内变化。4项研究报告了组间步态速度和/或耐力有显著改善,2项研究报告了组内变化。大多数运动是在运动器械上坐着、仰卧或俯卧时进行的。最常见的干预目标是膝关节伸展。
研究总体上改善了力量,但只有两项研究报告了组间步态有潜在的有意义变化。未来旨在改善步态的力量干预研究可能会考虑超出最小强度的剂量以增强力量,并探索与步行任务特定相关的肌肉目标、姿势和模式。