Massimelli Julia, Denaro Kameryn, Sato Brian, Kadandale Pavan, Boury Nancy
University of California, Irvine, CA, 92697.
Iowa State University, Ames, IA, 50011.
J Microbiol Biol Educ. 2019 Jun 28;20(2). doi: 10.1128/jmbe..v20i2.1690. eCollection 2019.
Quantitative data analysis skills are basic competencies students in a STEM field should master. In this article, we describe a classroom activity using isolated figures from papers as a simple exercise to practice data analysis skills. We call this approach Just Figures. With this technique, instructors find figures from primary papers that address key concepts related to several of their course learning objectives. These figures are assigned as homework prior to class discussion. In class, instructors teach the lesson and include a 10- to 20-minute discussion of the figures assigned. Frequent and repeated discussion of paper figures during class increased students' confidence in reading and analyzing data. The Just Figures approach also increased student accuracy when interpreting data. After six weeks of Just Figures practice, students scored, on average, three points higher on a 20-point data analysis assessment instrument than they had done before the Just Figures exercises. In addition, a course in which students consistently practiced Just Figures performed just as well on the data analysis assessment instrument and on a class exam dedicated to paper reading compared with courses where students practiced reading three entire papers. The Just Figures method is easy to implement and can effectively improve student data analysis skills in microbiology classrooms.
定量数据分析技能是理工科领域学生应掌握的基本能力。在本文中,我们描述了一种课堂活动,即使用论文中的孤立图表作为练习数据分析技能的简单练习。我们将这种方法称为“仅图表法”。通过这种技术,教师从主要论文中找到与他们的几个课程学习目标相关的关键概念的图表。这些图表在课堂讨论之前作为作业布置。在课堂上,教师授课,并对布置的图表进行10到20分钟的讨论。课堂上对论文图表的频繁和反复讨论提高了学生阅读和分析数据的信心。“仅图表法”在解释数据时也提高了学生的准确性。经过六周的“仅图表法”练习,学生在一份20分的数据分析评估工具上的平均得分比在进行“仅图表法”练习之前高出三分。此外,与学生练习阅读三篇完整论文的课程相比,一门学生持续练习“仅图表法”的课程在数据分析评估工具和专门用于论文阅读的课堂考试中的表现同样出色。“仅图表法”易于实施,并且可以有效地提高微生物学课堂上学生的数据分析技能。