Abdelaal Ashraf Abdelaal Mohamed, Abdulaziz Ehab Mohamed
Department of Physical Therapy for Cardiovascular/Respiratory Disorder and Geriatrics, Faculty of Physical Therapy, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt.
Consultant in Nephrology and Internal Medicine, National Institute of Liver, Gastroenterology & Infectious Diseases, Cairo, Egypt.
J Exerc Rehabil. 2019 Jun 30;15(3):472-480. doi: 10.12965/jer.1938176.088. eCollection 2019 Jun.
Physical performance (PP) and functional balance (FB) abnormalities are frequently encountered problems in patients on maintenance renal hemodialysis (MRH). Although the exercise therapy is an adjunctive to the routine medical care for patients with chronic kidney disease of various stages; but the benefits as well as the long-term effects of different exercises on the PP and FB in patients on MRH are not yet fully described. In this study; Sixty-six patients on MRH (36 males, 30 females), age 35-45 years, were randomly assigned into one of the three groups: aerobic exercise training group (AETG), resistance exercise training group (RETG), and control group (CG). The PP (evaluated using the 6-min walk test "6MWT") and the FB (evaluated via the Berg balance scale "BBS") were the main study outcomes evaluated prestudy (evaluation-1), after 3 months (evaluation-2) and 2 months poststudy cessation (evaluation-3). Results revealed that the PP and FB mean values and percentages of changes at evaluation-2 were 444.25±21.83 (33.1%), 413.57±28.55 (22.52%), 337±12.23 (0.33%) m, 50.05±0.89 (22.95%), 49.95±2.06 (22.52%), 41.28±1.75 (0.94%) for AETG, RETG, and CG respectively. At evaluation-3; the PP and FB mean values and the percentage of changes were 425±21.49 (27.36), 366.86±17.47 (8.5%), 336.68 (0.42%) m, 44.4±1.85 (8.06%), 42.95±2.04 (5.003%), 39.48±2.06 (-4.44%) for AETG, RETG, and CG respectively. In conclusions; both aerobic exercise training (AET) and resistance exercise training (RET) have favorable effects, with the AET has higher short and long-term favorable effects on the PP and FB than RET in patients on MRH.
身体机能(PP)和功能平衡(FB)异常是维持性肾血液透析(MRH)患者中经常遇到的问题。尽管运动疗法是各阶段慢性肾脏病患者常规医疗护理的辅助手段;但不同运动对MRH患者PP和FB的益处及长期影响尚未得到充分描述。在本研究中,66例年龄在35 - 45岁的MRH患者(36例男性,30例女性)被随机分为三组之一:有氧运动训练组(AETG)、抗阻运动训练组(RETG)和对照组(CG)。PP(使用6分钟步行试验“6MWT”评估)和FB(通过伯格平衡量表“BBS”评估)是在研究前(评估-1)、3个月后(评估-2)和研究停止后2个月(评估-3)评估的主要研究结果。结果显示,AETG、RETG和CG在评估-2时PP和FB的平均值及变化百分比分别为444.25±21.83(33.1%)、413.57±28.55(22.52%)、337±12.23(0.33%)米,50.05±0.89(22.95%)、49.95±2.06(22.52%)、41.28±1.75(0.94%)。在评估-3时,AETG、RETG和CG的PP和FB平均值及变化百分比分别为425±21.49(27.36)、366.86±17.47(8.5%)、336.68(0.42%)米,44.4±1.85(8.06%)、42.95±2.04(5.003%)、39.48±2.06(-4.44%)。总之,有氧运动训练(AET)和抗阻运动训练(RET)都有有益效果,在MRH患者中,AET对PP和FB的短期和长期有益效果均高于RET。