Tuppin Philippe, Rivière Sébastien, Deutsch David, Gastaldi-Menager Christelle, Sabaté Jean-Marc
Caisse Nationale d'Assurance Maladie (CNAM), Direction de la Stratégie des Études et des Statistiques, 26-50, avenue du Professeur André Lemierre, 75986 Paris Cedex 20, France.
Caisse Nationale d'Assurance Maladie (CNAM), Paris, France.
Therap Adv Gastroenterol. 2019 Jul 12;12:1756284819853790. doi: 10.1177/1756284819853790. eCollection 2019.
Gastrointestinal therapeutic drugs (GTDs) are extensively prescribed. The aim of this study was to investigate the characteristics of GTD use in a large population: the French general health scheme beneficiaries (87% of the 66 million inhabitants) in 2016.
The national health data system was used to identify individual characteristics, diseases and GTD classes reimbursed, together with the costs, using anatomical therapeutic chemical class.
Among the 57.5 million individuals included, 45% received at least one reimbursement among the 130 million prescriptions reimbursed (90% prescribed by a general practitioner): proton-pump inhibitors (PPI; A02BC: 24%), drugs for functional gastrointestinal disorders (A03: 20%), drugs for constipation (A06: 10%), antidiarrheals, intestinal anti-inflammatory/anti-infective agents (A07: 10%), antiemetics and antinauseants (A04: 7%), other drugs for acid-related disorders (A02X: 6%), other drugs for peptic ulcer and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (A02BX: 4.5%), antacids (A02A: 1.5%). The overall cost of reimbursed GTDs was €707 million and the mean cost per user was €28. Marked variations were observed according to age, sex, and disease. The rates of at least one reimbursement among infants were A07: 28%, A03: 17%, A02BX: 9%, A02X: 7%, A02BC: 6% and A06: 5%. Women more frequently received a reimbursement than men for each GTD class. Reimbursement rates also varied according to health status (end-stage renal disease A02BC: 66%, pregnancy A03: 53%, A04: 11%), treatments (people with at least six reimbursements for nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in 2016 A02BC: 62%). Chronic GTD use (>10 reimbursements/year) was observed in 19% of people with at least one A02BC reimbursement, A02BX: 11%, A03: 7%, A04: 2%, A06: 17% and A07: 3%.
This study demonstrates extensive and chronic use of GTD in France, raising the question of their relevance according to current guidelines. They must be disseminated to general practitioners, who are the main prescribers of these drugs.
胃肠道治疗药物(GTDs)的处方量很大。本研究的目的是调查大量人群(2016年法国全民健康保险计划的受益人,占6600万居民的87%)使用GTDs的特征。
利用国家卫生数据系统,结合成本,确定个人特征、疾病以及按解剖治疗化学分类法报销的GTDs类别。
在纳入的5750万人中,在报销的1.3亿张处方中,45%的人至少获得了一次报销(90%由全科医生开具):质子泵抑制剂(PPI;A02BC:24%)、功能性胃肠病药物(A03:20%)、便秘药物(A06:10%)、止泻药、肠道抗炎/抗感染药物(A07:10%)、止吐药和抗恶心药(A04:7%)、其他酸相关疾病药物(A02X:6%)、其他消化性溃疡和胃食管反流病药物(A02BX:4.5%)、抗酸剂(A02A:1.5%)。报销的GTDs总费用为7.07亿欧元,每位使用者的平均费用为28欧元。根据年龄、性别和疾病观察到明显差异。婴儿中至少获得一次报销的比例为:A07:28%,A03:17%,A02BX:9%,A02X:7%,A02BC:6%,A06:5%。在每个GTDs类别中,女性获得报销的频率高于男性。报销率也因健康状况(终末期肾病A02BC:66%,妊娠A03:53%,A04:11%)、治疗情况(2016年至少有6次非甾体抗炎药报销的人群A02BC:62%)而有所不同。在至少有一次A02BC报销的人群中,19%的人长期使用GTDs(每年报销>10次),A02BX:11%,A03:7%,A04:2%,A06:17%,A07:3%。
本研究表明法国存在GTDs的广泛和长期使用情况,根据当前指南,这引发了其相关性的问题。必须将这些指南传播给全科医生,因为他们是这些药物的主要开方者。