Welten Institute, Open University of the Netherlands, 6419 AT Heerlen, The Netherlands.
Cologne Game Lab, TH Köln, 51063 Köln, Germany.
Sensors (Basel). 2019 Jul 23;19(14):3244. doi: 10.3390/s19143244.
Sensors can monitor physical attributes and record multimodal data in order to provide feedback. The application calligraphy trainer, exploits these affordances in the context of handwriting learning. It records the expert's handwriting performance to compute an expert model. The application then uses the expert model to provide guidance and feedback to the learners. However, new learners can be overwhelmed by the feedback as handwriting learning is a tedious task. This paper presents the pilot study done with the calligraphy trainer to evaluate the mental effort induced by various types of feedback provided by the application. Ten participants, five in the control group and five in the treatment group, who were Ph.D. students in the technology-enhanced learning domain, took part in the study. The participants used the application to learn three characters from the Devanagari script. The results show higher mental effort in the treatment group when all types of feedback are provided simultaneously. The mental efforts for individual feedback were similar to the control group. In conclusion, the feedback provided by the calligraphy trainer does not impose high mental effort and, therefore, the design considerations of the calligraphy trainer can be insightful for multimodal feedback designers.
传感器可以监测物理属性并记录多模态数据,以提供反馈。书法练习应用程序利用了这些功能来进行手写学习。它记录专家的手写表现,以计算专家模型。然后,应用程序使用专家模型为学习者提供指导和反馈。然而,新的学习者可能会被反馈淹没,因为手写学习是一项繁琐的任务。本文介绍了使用书法练习应用程序进行的初步研究,以评估应用程序提供的各种类型反馈所引起的心理努力。十名参与者,五名在对照组,五名在治疗组,他们都是技术增强学习领域的博士生,参加了这项研究。参与者使用该应用程序学习了三个来自梵文脚本的字符。结果表明,当同时提供所有类型的反馈时,治疗组的心理努力更高。单独反馈的心理努力与对照组相似。总之,书法练习应用程序提供的反馈不会造成很高的心理努力,因此,书法练习应用程序的设计考虑因素可以为多模态反馈设计人员提供有价值的见解。