School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA.
School of Industrial Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA; Purdue Institute for Integrative Neuroscience, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA.
Neuroimage. 2019 Nov 15;202:115967. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2019.06.045. Epub 2019 Jul 25.
Multi-site studies are becoming important to increase statistical power, enhance generalizability, and to improve the likelihood of pooling relevant subgroups together-activities which are otherwise limited by the availability of subjects or funds at a single site. Even with harmonized imaging sequences, site-dependent variability can mask the advantages of these multi-site studies. The aim of this study was to assess multi-site reproducibility in resting-state functional connectivity "fingerprints", and to improve identifiability of functional connectomes. The individual fingerprinting of functional connectivity profiles is promising due to its potential as a robust neuroimaging biomarker with which to draw single-subject inferences. We evaluated, on two independent multi-site datasets, individual fingerprints in test-retest visit pairs within and across two sites and present a generalized framework based on principal component analysis to improve identifiability. Those principal components that maximized differential identifiability of a training dataset were used as an orthogonal connectivity basis to reconstruct the individual functional connectomes of training and validation sets. The optimally reconstructed functional connectomes showed a substantial improvement in individual fingerprinting of the subjects within and across the two sites and test-retest visit pairs relative to the original data. A notable increase in ICC values for functional edges and resting-state networks were also observed for reconstructed functional connectomes. Improvements in identifiability were not found to be affected by global signal regression. Post-hoc analyses assessed the effect of the number of fMRI volumes on identifiability and showed that multi-site differential identifiability was for all cases maximized after optimal reconstruction. Finally, the generalizability of the optimal set of orthogonal basis of each dataset was evaluated through a leave-one-out procedure. Overall, results demonstrate that the data-driven framework presented in this study systematically improves identifiability in resting-state functional connectomes in multi-site studies.
多站点研究对于提高统计功效、增强普遍性以及提高将相关亚组汇集在一起的可能性变得越来越重要——这些活动在单个站点的情况下受到可用对象或资金的限制。即使采用了协调的成像序列,站点依赖性变异性也可能掩盖这些多站点研究的优势。本研究旨在评估静息态功能连接“指纹”的多站点可重复性,并提高功能连接组的可识别性。由于其作为稳健的神经影像学生物标志物的潜力,可以对单个对象进行推断,因此功能连接谱的个体指纹具有很大的发展前景。我们在两个独立的多站点数据集上评估了两个站点内和站点间的测试-重测访问对的个体指纹,并提出了基于主成分分析的广义框架来提高可识别性。那些最大化训练数据集差异可识别性的主成分被用作正交连接基础,以重建训练和验证集的个体功能连接组。与原始数据相比,最优重建的功能连接组在两个站点内和站点间以及测试-重测访问对的个体指纹识别方面有了很大的提高。还观察到功能边缘和静息态网络的 ICC 值显著增加。可识别性的提高没有发现受到全局信号回归的影响。事后分析评估了 fMRI 体积数量对可识别性的影响,并表明在最优重建后,所有情况下多站点差异可识别性都得到了最大化。最后,通过留一法程序评估了每个数据集最优正交基集的通用性。总的来说,结果表明,本研究提出的数据驱动框架系统地提高了多站点研究中静息态功能连接组的可识别性。