School of Nursing, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Clinical Epidemiology Program, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
J Adv Nurs. 2019 Dec;75(12):3448-3470. doi: 10.1111/jan.14165. Epub 2019 Sep 4.
To conduct a concept analysis of clinical practice contexts (work environments) in health care.
Context is increasingly recognized as important to the development, delivery, and understanding of implementation strategies; however, conceptual clarity about what comprises context is lacking.
Modified Walker and Avant concept analysis comprised of five steps: (1) concept selection; (2) determination of aims; (3) identification of uses of context; (4) determination of its defining attributes; and (5) definition of its empirical referents.
A wide range of databases were systematically searched from inception to August 2014. Empirical articles were included if a definition and/or attributes of context were reported. Theoretical articles were included if they reported a model, theory, or framework of context or where context was a component. Double independent screening and data extraction were conducted. Analysis was iterative, involving organizing and reorganizing until a framework of domains, attributes. and features of context emerged.
We identified 15,972 references, of which 70 satisfied our inclusion criteria. In total, 201 unique features of context were identified, of these 89 were shared (reported in two or more studies). The 89 shared features were grouped into 21 attributes of context which were further categorized into six domains of context.
This study resulted in a framework of domains, attributes and features of context. These attributes and features, if assessed and used to tailor implementation activities, hold promise for improved research implementation in clinical practice.
对医疗保健中的临床实践环境(工作环境)进行概念分析。
环境越来越被认为对实施策略的发展、实施和理解很重要;但是,对于环境包含哪些内容的概念理解还不够清晰。
经过修改的 Walker 和 Avant 概念分析包括五个步骤:(1)概念选择;(2)确定目的;(3)确定环境的用途;(4)确定其定义属性;(5)定义其实证参考。
从开始到 2014 年 8 月,系统地搜索了各种数据库。如果报告了环境的定义和/或属性,则将实证文章包括在内。如果报告了环境的模型、理论或框架,或者环境是其中的一个组成部分,则将理论文章包括在内。进行了两次独立的筛选和数据提取。分析是迭代的,涉及到组织和重新组织,直到出现环境的领域、属性和特征框架。
我们确定了 15972 篇参考文献,其中 70 篇符合我们的纳入标准。总共确定了 201 个独特的环境特征,其中 89 个是共享的(在两个或更多研究中报告)。这 89 个共享特征被分为环境的 21 个属性,这些属性进一步分为环境的六个领域。
本研究提出了环境的领域、属性和特征框架。如果评估和用于调整实施活动,这些属性和特征有望提高临床实践中的研究实施。