Porat-Dahlerbruch Joshua, Ratz Shoshana, Ellen Moriah
Department of Acute and Tertiary Care, School of Nursing, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
Department of Health Policy and Management, Guilford Glazer Faculty of Business & Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be'er Sheva, Israel.
Int J Health Policy Manag. 2024;13:8194. doi: 10.34172/ijhpm.2023.8194. Epub 2024 Jan 22.
Nurse practitioners (NPs)-nurses with advanced training who can provide and prescribe care-are increasingly prevalent internationally. The growth of NPs can be attributed to physician shortages, growing demand for health services, and the professionalization of nursing. Ensuring efficacious integration of NPs into the health system is critical for maximizing their impact on patient and system outcomes. Nonetheless, there is a dearth of information on practical policy interventions facilitating the successful integration of NPs. Effective policy interventions should capture the perspectives of actors at all levels of the health system-ie, national and organizational levels. This study aimed to delineate a taxonomy of policy interventions for integrating NPs into health systems. This paper presents a taxonomy developed among gerontology NPs in Israel.
This qualitative descriptive study used multiple perspective, one-to-one interviews with four professional groups-national policy-makers, organizational administrators, NPs, and physicians. Data were analyzed using deductive content analysis. Analysis accounted for diverging and converging patterns between professional groups.
There were 58 participants across the four professional groups. The national-level domain interventions include marketing, workforce development, professional licensure and regulation, financial incentives, stakeholder cooperation, education and training programs, and national-level research. Organizational domain interventions included organizational guidelines, infrastructure development and resource allocation, interprofessional leadership engagement, and organizational messaging. Unit- and care-team domain interventions included interprofessional experience and exposure, team communication, and mentorship.
The taxonomy's trichotomy of three health system level domains describes the relationship between national and organizational policy interventions. Adopting these interventions may result in an improved response to provider shortages. Policies insufficiently addressing role clarity and workforce retention resulted in poor integration and a failure to efficaciously combat workforce shortages. Future work will expand the focus of this preliminary taxonomy by further development and testing with international participants.
执业护士(NPs)——经过高级培训、能够提供并开具护理处方的护士——在国际上日益普遍。执业护士数量的增长可归因于医生短缺、对医疗服务需求的增加以及护理工作的专业化。确保执业护士有效融入医疗体系对于最大化其对患者和系统结果的影响至关重要。尽管如此,关于促进执业护士成功融入的实际政策干预措施的信息却很匮乏。有效的政策干预措施应涵盖医疗体系各级行为者的观点,即国家和组织层面。本研究旨在勾勒出将执业护士融入医疗体系的政策干预分类法。本文介绍了在以色列老年病学执业护士中制定的一种分类法。
这项定性描述性研究采用多视角、一对一访谈四个专业群体——国家政策制定者、组织管理人员、执业护士和医生。使用演绎性内容分析法对数据进行分析。分析考虑了专业群体之间的不同和趋同模式。
四个专业群体共有58名参与者。国家级领域干预措施包括营销、劳动力发展、专业许可与监管、经济激励、利益相关者合作、教育培训项目以及国家级研究。组织领域干预措施包括组织指南、基础设施发展与资源分配、跨专业领导力参与以及组织信息传达。单位和护理团队领域干预措施包括跨专业经验与接触、团队沟通以及指导。
该分类法对医疗体系三个层面领域的三分法描述了国家和组织政策干预之间的关系。采用这些干预措施可能会改善对医疗服务提供者短缺的应对。未能充分解决角色清晰度和劳动力留用问题的政策导致整合不佳,无法有效应对劳动力短缺。未来的工作将通过与国际参与者进一步开展开发和测试,扩大这一初步分类法的关注点。