Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2020 Feb;99(2):153-166. doi: 10.1111/aogs.13702. Epub 2019 Sep 10.
Severe early-onset fetal growth restriction is an obstetric condition with significant risks of perinatal mortality, major and minor neonatal morbidity, and long-term health sequelae. The prognosis of a fetus is influenced by the extent of prematurity and fetal weight. Clinical care is individually adjusted. In literature, survival rates vary and studies often only include live-born neonates with missing rates of antenatal death. This systematic review aims to summarize the literature on mortality and morbidity.
A broad literature search was conducted in OVID MEDLINE from 2000 to 26 April 2019 to identify studies on fetal growth restriction and perinatal death. Studies were excluded when all included children were born before 2000 because (neonatal) health care has considerably improved since this period. Studies were included that described fetal growth restriction diagnosed before 32 weeks of gestation and antenatal mortality and neonatal mortality and/or morbidity as outcome. Quality of evidence was rated with the GRADE instrument.
Of the 2604 publications identified, 25 studies, reporting 2895 pregnancies, were included in the systematic review. Overall risk of bias in most studies was judged as low. The quality of evidence was generally rated as very low to moderate, except for 3 large well-designed randomized controlled trials. When combining all data on mortality, in 355 of 2895 pregnancies (12%) the fetus died antenatally, 192 died in the neonatal period (8% of live-born neonates) and 2347 (81% of all pregnancies) children survived. Of the neonatal morbidities recorded, respiratory distress syndrome (34% of the live-born neonates), retinopathy of prematurity (13%) and sepsis (30%) were most common. Of 476 children that underwent neurodevelopmental assessment, 58 (12% of surviving children, 9% of all pregnancies) suffered from cognitive impairment and/or cerebral palsy.
When combining the data of 25 included studies, survival in fetal growth restriction pregnancies, diagnosed before 32 weeks of gestation, was 81%. Neurodevelopmental impairment was assessed in a minority of surviving children. Individual prognostic counseling on the basis of these results is hampered by differences in patient and pregnancy characteristics within the included patient groups.
严重的早发型胎儿生长受限是一种产科疾病,围产期死亡率、新生儿主要和次要发病率以及长期健康后遗症的风险显著增加。胎儿的预后受早产程度和胎儿体重的影响。临床护理是个体化调整的。在文献中,存活率有所不同,研究通常只包括存活新生儿,而忽略了产前死亡的发生率。本系统评价旨在总结胎儿生长受限和围产儿死亡的文献。
在 OVID MEDLINE 进行了广泛的文献检索,检索时间为 2000 年至 2019 年 4 月 26 日,以确定关于胎儿生长受限和围产儿死亡的研究。当所有纳入的儿童均在 2000 年前出生时,研究将被排除在外,因为自那时以来(新生儿)的医疗保健已经有了相当大的改善。纳入的研究描述了在 32 周妊娠前诊断的胎儿生长受限以及产前死亡和新生儿死亡和/或发病率作为结局。使用 GRADE 工具对证据质量进行评级。
在确定的 2604 篇文献中,有 25 项研究,共 2895 例妊娠,纳入了系统评价。大多数研究的整体偏倚风险被判断为低。证据质量通常被评为极低至中度,除了 3 项大型设计良好的随机对照试验。当综合所有死亡率数据时,在 2895 例妊娠中,有 355 例(12%)胎儿在产前死亡,192 例在新生儿期死亡(存活新生儿的 8%),2347 例(所有妊娠的 81%)儿童存活。记录的新生儿发病率中,呼吸窘迫综合征(存活新生儿的 34%)、早产儿视网膜病变(13%)和败血症(30%)最为常见。在接受神经发育评估的 476 名儿童中,有 58 名(存活儿童的 12%,所有妊娠的 9%)患有认知障碍和/或脑瘫。
综合 25 项纳入研究的数据,在 32 周妊娠前诊断的胎儿生长受限妊娠中,存活率为 81%。只有少数存活儿童接受了神经发育障碍评估。基于这些结果进行个体化预后咨询,受到纳入患者组内患者和妊娠特征差异的阻碍。