BehaviourWorks Australia, Monash Sustainable Development Institute, Monash University, 8 Scenic Boulevard, Clayton, Melbourne, VIC, 3800, Australia.
BMC Med Educ. 2019 Aug 14;19(1):311. doi: 10.1186/s12909-019-1735-3.
General practitioners (GPs), or family practitioners, are tasked with prescribing medications that can be harmful to the community if they are inappropriately prescribed or used (e.g. opioids). Educational programs, such as educational outreach (EO), are designed to change the behaviour of health professionals. The purpose of this study was to identify the efficacy of EO programs at changing the prescribing behaviour of GPs.
This study included an evidence and practice review, comprising a rapid review supplemented by interviews with people who are familiar with EO implementation for regulation purposes. Seven databases were searched using terms related to health professionals and prescribing. Systematic and narrative reviews published in English after 2007 were included. Non-statistical analysis was used to report intervention efficacy. Three government representatives participated in semi-structured interviews to aid in understanding the relevance of review findings to the Victorian context. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and thematically analysed for emerging themes.
Fourteen reviews were identified for the evidence review. Isolated (e.g. EO program delivered by itself) and multifaceted (e.g. EO program supplemented by other interventions) programs were found to change prescribing behaviours. However, limited evidence suggests that EO can successfully change prescribing behaviours specific to GPs. Isolated EO can successfully change health professional prescribing behaviours, although cheaper alternatives such as letters might be just as effective. Multifaceted EO can also successfully change health professional prescribing behaviours, especially in older adults, but it remains unclear as to what combination of interventions works best. Success factors for EO reported by government representatives included programs having practical rather than didactic foci; making EO compulsory; focussing EO on preventing adverse events; using monetary or professional development incentives; and in-person delivery.
Educational outreach can successfully change prescribing behaviours but evidence specific to GPs is lacking. Key characteristics of EO that could optimise success include ensuring the EO program is tailored, involves practical learning and uses incentives that are meaningful to clinicians.
全科医生(GP)或家庭医生负责开具药物,如果开具不当或使用不当(例如阿片类药物),这些药物可能对社区造成危害。教育计划,如教育外展(EO)旨在改变卫生专业人员的行为。本研究的目的是确定 EO 计划在改变全科医生的处方行为方面的功效。
本研究包括证据和实践综述,包括快速综述和为监管目的而对熟悉 EO 实施情况的人员进行访谈。使用与卫生专业人员和处方相关的术语搜索了七个数据库。纳入了 2007 年后以英文发表的系统评价和叙述性评价。使用非统计分析报告干预效果。三名政府代表参加了半结构化访谈,以帮助理解审查结果与维多利亚州背景的相关性。访谈逐字转录,并进行主题分析以提取主题。
为证据综述确定了 14 项综述。发现孤立(例如单独提供 EO 计划)和多方面(例如,EO 计划辅以其他干预措施)的计划可以改变处方行为。然而,有限的证据表明 EO 可以成功改变 GP 的特定处方行为。孤立的 EO 可以成功改变卫生专业人员的处方行为,尽管价格更便宜的替代方案,如信件,可能同样有效。多方面的 EO 也可以成功改变卫生专业人员的处方行为,特别是在老年人中,但尚不清楚哪种干预组合效果最佳。政府代表报告的 EO 成功因素包括计划具有实践而非说教重点;使 EO 成为强制性的;专注于预防不良事件的 EO;使用金钱或职业发展激励措施;以及面对面的交付。
教育外展可以成功改变处方行为,但缺乏针对 GP 的具体证据。能优化成功的 EO 的关键特征包括确保 EO 计划是量身定制的,涉及实践学习并使用对临床医生有意义的激励措施。