Varse Fatemeh, Janani Leila, Moradi Yousef, Solaymani-Dodaran Masoud, Baradaran Hamid Reza, Rimaz Shahnaz
Student Research Committee, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Preventive Medicine and Public Health Research Center, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2019 Apr 30;33:37. doi: 10.34171/mjiri.33.37. eCollection 2019.
Randomized clinical trials have been considered as the gold standard for evaluating the effectiveness and safety of medical interventions; however, there are major barriers to their design, conduct, analysis, and reporting. They are multidisciplinary and involve different steps and face a variety of challenges that may vary from one country to another. The aim of this study was to provide a comprehensive presentation of the challenges of clinical trial studies in different steps including design, conducting, analysis, and reporting. In this study, all original articles conducted during 1991-2017 that reviewed the barriers to clinical trial studies at one of the steps of design, conducing, analysis, and reporting of the results in Medline (through PubMed), Embase, Web of Sciences, Scopus, and Google Scholar were considered. The searched keywords were as follow: challenges, barriers, and randomized clinical trial. The following barriers in different steps of randomized clinical trials were identified: general barriers include insufficient knowledge and understanding of clinical research and research methodology, barriers to ethical and regulatory systems, and lack of funding. The investigator-initiated trials may face similar problems to those of sponsor-initiated trials, such as handling regulatory systems, administrative and financial issues, multiple languages, and different patient compensation approaches. The challenge related to design was poor planning. Other challenges were lack of manpower and financial resources, inappropriate statistical methods for analysis (analysis challenges), and challenges related to reporting which include selective reporting. Based on the results of this systematic review, the most important challenges were barriers related to handling ethical and regulatory systems, patient recruitment, and lack of budget and skilled staff for conducting clinical trials. Training to improve the quality of randomized clinical trial studies in different steps and levels was the most important recommendation in these studies.
随机临床试验被视为评估医学干预措施有效性和安全性的金标准;然而,其设计、实施、分析和报告存在重大障碍。它们是多学科的,涉及不同步骤,面临着可能因国家而异的各种挑战。本研究的目的是全面介绍临床试验研究在设计、实施、分析和报告等不同步骤中所面临的挑战。在本研究中,考虑了1991年至2017年期间发表在Medline(通过PubMed)、Embase、Web of Sciences、Scopus和Google Scholar上的所有原创文章,这些文章回顾了临床试验研究在设计、实施、分析和结果报告等步骤之一中的障碍。搜索关键词如下:挑战、障碍和随机临床试验。确定了随机临床试验不同步骤中的以下障碍:一般障碍包括对临床研究和研究方法的知识和理解不足、伦理和监管系统的障碍以及资金缺乏。研究者发起的试验可能面临与申办者发起的试验类似的问题,如处理监管系统、行政和财务问题、多种语言以及不同的患者补偿方式。与设计相关的挑战是规划不善。其他挑战包括人力资源和资金短缺、分析时统计方法不当(分析挑战)以及与报告相关的挑战,包括选择性报告。基于这项系统评价的结果,最重要的挑战是与处理伦理和监管系统、患者招募以及缺乏开展临床试验的预算和技术人员相关的障碍。在这些研究中,最重要的建议是进行培训,以提高随机临床试验研究在不同步骤和层面的质量。