Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Sci Rep. 2019 Sep 24;9(1):13769. doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-50391-x.
Bispectral index (BIS), a useful marker of anaesthetic depth, is calculated by a statistical multivariate model using nonlinear functions of electroencephalography-based subparameters. However, only a portion of the proprietary algorithm has been identified. We investigated the BIS algorithm using clinical big data and machine learning techniques. Retrospective data from 5,427 patients who underwent BIS monitoring during general anaesthesia were used, of which 80% and 20% were used as training datasets and test datasets, respectively. A histogram of data points was plotted to define five BIS ranges representing the depth of anaesthesia. Decision tree analysis was performed to determine the electroencephalography subparameters and their thresholds for classifying five BIS ranges. Random sample consensus regression analyses were performed using the subparameters to derive multiple linear regression models of BIS calculation in five BIS ranges. The performance of the decision tree and regression models was externally validated with positive predictive value and median absolute error, respectively. A four-level depth decision tree was built with four subparameters such as burst suppression ratio, power of electromyogram, 95% spectral edge frequency, and relative beta ratio. Positive predictive values were 100%, 80%, 80%, 85% and 89% in the order of increasing BIS in the five BIS ranges. The average of median absolute errors of regression models was 4.1 as BIS value. A data driven BIS calculation algorithm using multiple electroencephalography subparameters with different weights depending on BIS ranges has been proposed. The results may help the anaesthesiologists interpret the erroneous BIS values observed during clinical practice.
脑电双频指数(BIS)是一种有用的麻醉深度标志物,通过使用基于脑电图的子参数的非线性函数的统计多变量模型来计算。然而,只有部分专有的算法已经确定。我们使用临床大数据和机器学习技术研究了 BIS 算法。使用了在全身麻醉期间接受 BIS 监测的 5427 名患者的回顾性数据,其中 80%和 20%分别用作训练数据集和测试数据集。绘制数据点的直方图以定义代表麻醉深度的五个 BIS 范围。进行决策树分析以确定脑电图子参数及其用于将五个 BIS 范围分类的阈值。使用子参数对随机抽样一致回归分析进行回归分析,以得出五个 BIS 范围内 BIS 计算的多元线性回归模型。使用正预测值和中位数绝对误差分别对决策树和回归模型的性能进行外部验证。使用四个子参数(如爆发抑制比、肌电图功率、95%光谱边缘频率和相对β比)构建了一个四级深度决策树。在五个 BIS 范围内,BIS 值依次增加,正预测值分别为 100%、80%、80%、85%和 89%。回归模型的中位数绝对误差的平均值为 4.1 作为 BIS 值。提出了一种基于多个脑电图子参数的 BIS 计算算法,该算法根据 BIS 范围使用不同的权重。结果可能有助于麻醉师解释在临床实践中观察到的错误 BIS 值。