Department of Criminology, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida, United States of America.
Department of Criminology & Criminal Justice, University of Texas at San Antonio, San Antonio, Texas, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2019 Oct 9;14(10):e0222996. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0222996. eCollection 2019.
Since 1990, the world's homicide rate has declined by nearly 20%. While prior research has documented parallel homicide declines across many individual countries, the causes of a shared international homicide decline remain unknown. Drawing on a worldwide process of population ageing, and on research linking age to criminal activity, this study investigates the contribution of global demographic shifts to the international homicide decline.
We draw from (1) a High Coverage Sample of 126 countries since 1990, and (2) a Long Series Sample of 26 countries since 1960 and utilize fixed-effect regressions to evaluate the impact of age structure on homicide trends. In addition, we use a quantile regression to explore variations in the relationship between age structure and homicide conditional on homicide levels.
Results using the High Coverage Sample suggest no relationship between age structure and homicide. However, results from the Long Series Sample suggest that changes in the relative size of countries' youth population is a major predictor of homicide trends since 1960. In exploring this divergence, we find that the influence of age structure on homicide becomes less evident as other risk factors for violence gain prominence. Thus, while high homicide countries had the most to gain from falling homicide rates, the safety benefits of an ageing population have been concentrated among the least violent countries.
While the homicide declines of individual countries have often been attributed to domestic policies, the universality of international homicide trends suggests the influence of broader global phenomenon. We find that countries' homicide trends are strongly associated with changes in the size of their youth populations, particularly where there are few competing criminogenic forces. Based on these results, we propose an explanation for the international homicide decline, while highlighting the importance of demographic patterns in explaining homicide trends.
自 1990 年以来,全球凶杀率下降了近 20%。尽管先前的研究记录了许多国家凶杀率的平行下降,但国际凶杀率下降的共同原因仍不清楚。本研究利用全球人口老龄化进程,以及将年龄与犯罪活动联系起来的研究,调查全球人口结构变化对国际凶杀率下降的贡献。
我们借鉴了(1)1990 年以来 126 个国家的高覆盖率样本,以及(2)自 1960 年以来 26 个国家的长序列样本,并利用固定效应回归来评估年龄结构对凶杀趋势的影响。此外,我们使用分位数回归来探索年龄结构与凶杀之间的关系在不同凶杀水平下的变化。
高覆盖率样本的结果表明,年龄结构与凶杀之间没有关系。然而,长序列样本的结果表明,自 1960 年以来,国家青年人口相对规模的变化是凶杀趋势的主要预测因素。在探索这种分歧时,我们发现,随着暴力其他风险因素的凸显,年龄结构对凶杀的影响变得不那么明显。因此,尽管高凶杀率国家从凶杀率下降中获益最多,但人口老龄化带来的安全效益主要集中在暴力程度最低的国家。
虽然个别国家的凶杀率下降通常归因于国内政策,但国际凶杀趋势的普遍性表明了更广泛的全球现象的影响。我们发现,各国的凶杀趋势与青年人口规模的变化密切相关,特别是在没有竞争犯罪因素的情况下。基于这些结果,我们提出了对国际凶杀率下降的解释,同时强调了人口模式在解释凶杀趋势方面的重要性。