Rao Parnandi Bhaskar, Mohanty Chitta Ranjan, Singh Neha, Mund Manisha, Patel Anamika, Sahoo Alok Kumar
Department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care, All India Institute of Medical Science, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India.
Department of Trauma and Emergency (Anaesthesia), All India Institute of Medical Science, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, India.
Anesth Essays Res. 2019 Jul-Sep;13(3):568-571. doi: 10.4103/aer.AER_103_19.
Venepuncture is an essential component of anaesthesia services. However, this invites pain generating the first negative experience with anaesthesia. Hence, relief of this pain carries considerable importance. Efficacy of ethyl chloride spray although studied, there is no consensus for the best way of application.
The present study was conducted to find an effective technique/method of ethyl chloride spray application to reduce venepuncture pain.
Adult patients posted for different anaesthesia procedures were randomised into three groups. Venepuncture was done either after installation of distilled water or spray of ethyl chloride either once to twice. Venepuncture pain was assessed with a 0-100 Numeric Rating Scale.
The analysis showed significant differences among the groups ( [2,96] = 66.27, < 0.05). The twice sprayed group experienced the least pain ([mean ± standard deviation [SD]] 16.67 ± 10.21), lower in the once spray group ([mean ± SD] 27.58 ± 13.24), and the controls had the highest pain score ([mean ± SD] 49.09 ± 11.28). Tukey's tests showed all the three groups differed significantly. The effect size was large, and the variability of the spray on the reduction of pain scores is 58% (η = 57.99).
Ethyl chloride spray effectively reduces the pain on venepuncture, especially when the vapocoolant is sprayed twice each over 5 s, and from a distance of 5 cm perpendicular to the skin.
静脉穿刺是麻醉服务的重要组成部分。然而,这会引发疼痛,产生患者对麻醉的首次负面体验。因此,缓解这种疼痛具有相当重要的意义。尽管已对氯乙烷喷雾剂的疗效进行了研究,但对于最佳应用方式尚无共识。
本研究旨在找到一种有效的氯乙烷喷雾剂应用技术/方法,以减轻静脉穿刺疼痛。
将拟行不同麻醉手术的成年患者随机分为三组。在静脉穿刺前,一组使用蒸馏水,另外两组分别喷雾氯乙烷一次或两次。采用0至100的数字评分量表评估静脉穿刺疼痛程度。
分析显示三组之间存在显著差异([2,96] = 66.27,P < 0.05)。喷雾两次的组疼痛程度最轻([均值±标准差[SD]] 16.67 ± 10.21),喷雾一次的组次之([均值±SD] 27.58 ± 13.24),对照组疼痛评分最高([均值±SD] 49.09 ± 11.28)。Tukey检验显示三组之间均存在显著差异。效应量较大,喷雾对疼痛评分降低的变异性为58%(η = 57.99)。
氯乙烷喷雾剂能有效减轻静脉穿刺疼痛,尤其是当在5秒内垂直于皮肤从5厘米远处对皮肤喷雾两次时。