Locke Jill, Lee Kristine, Cook Clayton R, Frederick Lindsay, Vázquez-Colón Cheryl, Ehrhart Mark G, Aarons Gregory A, Davis Chayna, Lyon Aaron R
University of Washington, Seattle, USA.
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, USA.
School Ment Health. 2019 Sep;11(3):379-399. doi: 10.1007/s12310-018-9292-1. Epub 2018 Oct 3.
Key features of the school environment can have a significant impact on teachers' effective use of evidence-based practices (EBP), yet implementation-specific organizational constructs have rarely been studied in the education sector. This study examined three aspects of the organizational implementation context (implementation leadership, climate, and citizenship behavior), which have been conceptualized and validated in other service settings. Focus groups with central office administrators, principals, and teachers were conducted to understand the applicability and conceptual boundaries of these organizational constructs in schools. Focus group transcripts were coded, and the results indicated both similarities and differences in their conceptualizations of implementation leadership, climate, and citizenship behavior in school. The data indicated that: (1) implementation leadership was largely present in schools with the addition of Distributed Leadership; (2) two implementation climate constructs were most clearly present (i.e., Focus on EBP and Educational Support for EBP) and two additional constructs (i.e., Existing Support to Deliver EBP and Prioritization of EBP) emerged as part of this construct; and (3) implementation citizenship behavior (Helping Others and Keeping Informed) was consistently acknowledged across schools and two new components emerged (i.e., Information Sharing and Observation/Feedback). Recommendations to researchers and community stakeholders are discussed.
学校环境的关键特征会对教师有效运用循证实践(EBP)产生重大影响,然而,教育领域中针对特定实施的组织架构却鲜有研究。本研究考察了组织实施背景的三个方面(实施领导力、氛围和公民行为),这些方面已在其他服务环境中得到概念化和验证。研究通过与中央办公室管理人员、校长和教师进行焦点小组讨论,以了解这些组织架构在学校中的适用性和概念边界。对焦点小组的文字记录进行了编码,结果显示,他们对学校实施领导力、氛围和公民行为的概念化既有相似之处,也有不同之处。数据表明:(1)在引入分布式领导力的学校中,实施领导力在很大程度上得以体现;(2)最明显存在两种实施氛围架构(即关注循证实践和对循证实践的教育支持),另外两种架构(即提供循证实践的现有支持和循证实践的优先级)也作为该架构的一部分出现;(3)实施公民行为(帮助他人和及时了解情况)在各学校中得到一致认可,并且出现了两个新的组成部分(即信息共享和观察/反馈)。文中还讨论了对研究人员和社区利益相关者的建议。