Baugh Aaron D, Vanderbilt Allison A, Baugh Reginald F
Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Emergency Medicine, Fulton County Health Center, Wauseon, OH, USA.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2019 Aug 21;10:667-676. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S196840. eCollection 2019.
Approximately one-third of the US population lives at or near the poverty line; however, this group makes up less than 7% of the incoming medical students. In the United Kingdom, the ratio of those of the highest social stratum is 30 times greater than those of the lowest to receive admission to medical school. In an effort to address health disparities and improve patient care, the authors argue that significant barriers must be overcome for the children of the disadvantaged to gain admission to medical school. Poverty is intergenerational and multidimensional. Familial wealth affects opportunities and educational attainment, starting when children are young and compounding as they get older. In addition, structural and other barriers exist to these students pursuing higher education, such as the realities of financial aid and the shadow of debt. Yet the medical education community can take steps to better support the children of the disadvantaged throughout their education, so they are able to reach medical school. If educators value the viewpoints and life experiences of diverse students enriching the learning environment, they must acknowledge the unique contributions that the children of the disadvantaged bring and work to increase their representation in medical schools and the physician workforce. We describe who the disadvantaged are contrasted with the metrics used by medical school admissions to identify them. The consequences of multiple facets of poverty on educational attainment are explored, including its interaction with other social identities, inter-generational impacts, and the importance of wealth versus annual income. Structural barriers to admission are reviewed. Given the multi-dimensional and cumulative nature of poverty, we conclude that absent significant and sustained intervention, medical school applicants from disadvantaged backgrounds will remain few and workforce issues affecting the care patients receive will not be resolved. The role of physicians and medical schools and advocating for necessary societal changes to alleviate this dynamic are highlighted.
美国约三分之一的人口生活在贫困线或接近贫困线的水平;然而,这一群体在即将入学的医学生中所占比例不到7%。在英国,社会阶层最高者被医学院录取的比例是最低者的30倍。为了解决健康差距问题并改善患者护理,作者认为,弱势群体的子女要进入医学院必须克服重大障碍。贫困具有代际性和多维度性。家庭财富会影响机会和教育程度,从孩子年幼时就开始产生影响,并随着他们年龄的增长而加剧。此外,这些学生在追求高等教育时还存在结构和其他障碍,比如经济援助的现实情况以及债务的阴影。然而,医学教育界可以采取措施,在弱势群体子女的整个教育过程中更好地支持他们,使他们能够进入医学院。如果教育工作者重视不同学生的观点和生活经历能丰富学习环境,就必须承认弱势群体子女所做出的独特贡献,并努力增加他们在医学院和医生队伍中的代表性。我们描述了弱势群体的构成,并与医学院招生用以识别他们的指标进行对比。探讨了贫困多方面因素对教育程度的影响,包括其与其他社会身份的相互作用、代际影响以及财富与年收入的重要性。审视了入学的结构障碍。鉴于贫困具有多维度和累积性的特点,我们得出结论,如果没有重大且持续的干预,来自弱势背景的医学院申请者将依然稀少,影响患者护理的劳动力问题也无法得到解决。文中强调了医生和医学院的作用,以及倡导进行必要的社会变革以缓解这种动态情况的重要性。