Castrillo-Fraile Victoria, Peña Elena Casas, Gabriel Y Galán José María Trejo, Delgado-López Pedro David, Collazo Carla, Cubo Esther
Department of Rehabilitation, Burgos University Hospital, Burgos, ES.
Department of Health Science, University of Valladolid, Valladolid, ES.
Tremor Other Hyperkinet Mov (N Y). 2019 Dec 5;9. doi: 10.7916/tohm.v0.688. eCollection 2019.
There is a growing interest in nonpharmacological approaches for essential tremor (ET), including tremor cancelation devices. However, the true efficacy of such devices in ET remains unclear.
A systematic literature review was conducted using standardized criteria regarding efficacy and comfortability. Devices focused on design or experimental testing in which tremor was simulated in a robot were excluded.
Out of 324 articles initially identified, 12 articles were included. Orthoses using biomechanical loading and neuromodulation with electrical stimulation, and external tremor cancelation devices, were the main interventions used to suppress tremor. All devices were designed to control tremor of the upper limbs at different anatomical locations. Overall, an average tremor attenuation of 50-98% was reported (level of evidence III). Interference with voluntary movements and portability was described as the main drawback.
In conclusion, this review highlights the growing interest in emerging tremor control devices and the importance of assessing comfort without affecting voluntary movements. However, the level of evidence regarding the efficacy of these tremor control devices remains low. An integrated multidisciplinary combination approach of engineering, robotics, physiology, physiotherapy, and clinical assessment is needed to improve the quality of non-pharmacological interventions for ET.
对于原发性震颤(ET)的非药物治疗方法,包括震颤消除装置,人们的兴趣日益浓厚。然而,此类装置在ET中的真正疗效仍不明确。
采用关于疗效和舒适性的标准化标准进行系统的文献综述。排除了专注于设计或实验测试(在机器人中模拟震颤)的装置。
在最初确定的324篇文章中,纳入了12篇。使用生物力学负荷和电刺激神经调节的矫形器以及外部震颤消除装置是用于抑制震颤的主要干预措施。所有装置均设计用于控制上肢不同解剖部位的震颤。总体而言,据报道平均震颤衰减为50%-98%(证据等级III)。对自主运动的干扰和便携性被描述为主要缺点。
总之,本综述强调了对新兴震颤控制装置日益增长的兴趣以及在不影响自主运动的情况下评估舒适性的重要性。然而,这些震颤控制装置疗效的证据水平仍然较低。需要工程学、机器人技术、生理学、物理治疗和临床评估的综合多学科联合方法来提高ET非药物干预的质量。