Borloti Elizeu, García Maria Victoria Hidalgo, Jiménez Virginia Sanchez, Sudbrack Maria Fátima Oliver
Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo - UFES, Av. Fernando Ferrari, 514 - Goiabeiras, Vitória, ES, CEP 29.075-910, Brazil.
Universidad de Sevilla - US, C/ S. Fernando, 4, C.P. 41004, Sevilla, Spain.
Psicol Reflex Crit. 2017 Jan 11;30(1):1. doi: 10.1186/s41155-016-0056-2.
Adolescents living in vulnerable regions are more exposed to risk factors for drug use. The prevention of such use in school is a public policy that needs evaluation. Based on technical criteria and derived from a mixed research, this article analyses the quality of school-based prevention of drug use in Vitória, state of Espírito Santo, Brazil, and proposes improvements. A checklist of quality elements was completed with data from 16 projects proposed by 99 teachers from public schools. In 10 projects (62.5%), the approximate quality index was above 0.50. The majority of projects fulfilled the requirement of theoretical foundation (81.25%) and some of the methodological (93.75%), design (75%) and implementation (62%) requirements. Other requirements were absent: the majority were not designed by the whole school community (87.5%), and the participation of the family (62.5%) or the students as mediators (62.5%) was not considered. In general, contents of life skills (87.5%), positive relationships and alternative activities to drug use (56.25%) were not included. Activities for reinforcing the content were not described in any of the projects, and evaluation activities were described in only a few (31.25%). Many projects did not describe the inclusion of the project in the school curriculum (62.5%). Although, considering all items of effectiveness, regardless of their weight, more than half of the projects had an above average quality. The present items provide quality to the projects, whereas absent items indicate shortcomings to be improved using some of the measures described in this study.
生活在脆弱地区的青少年更容易接触到吸毒风险因素。在学校预防此类行为是一项需要评估的公共政策。基于技术标准并源自混合研究,本文分析了巴西圣埃斯皮里图州维多利亚市学校吸毒预防工作的质量,并提出改进建议。利用公立学校99名教师提出的16个项目的数据,完成了一份质量要素清单。在10个项目(62.5%)中,近似质量指数高于0.50。大多数项目满足理论基础要求(81.25%)以及部分方法要求(93.75%)、设计要求(75%)和实施要求(62%)。其他要求则缺失:大多数项目并非由全校社区设计(87.5%),未考虑家庭参与(62.5%)或学生作为调解人的参与(62.5%)。总体而言,生活技能内容(87.5%)、积极关系以及吸毒替代活动(56.25%)未被纳入。所有项目均未描述强化内容的活动,只有少数项目(31.25%)描述了评估活动。许多项目未描述该项目如何纳入学校课程(62.5%)。尽管如此,考虑到所有有效性项目,无论其权重如何,超过一半的项目质量高于平均水平。现有项目提供了质量,而缺失项目则表明存在需要利用本研究中描述的一些措施加以改进的不足。