Center for Neuroscience and Cognitive Systems, Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, Rovereto, TN, Italy.
Center for Neuroscience and Cognitive Systems, Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, Rovereto, TN, Italy; Center for Mind/Brain Sciences (CIMeC), University of Trento, Rovereto, TN, Italy.
Neuroimage. 2020 May 1;211:116603. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2020.116603. Epub 2020 Feb 7.
Functional connectivity is derived from inter-regional correlations in spontaneous fluctuations of brain activity, and can be represented in terms of complete graphs with continuous (real-valued) edges. The structure of functional connectivity networks is strongly affected by signal processing procedures to remove the effects of motion, physiological noise and other sources of experimental error. However, in the absence of an established ground truth, it is difficult to determine the optimal procedure, and no consensus has been reached on the most effective approach to remove nuisance signals without unduly affecting the network intrinsic structural features. Here, we use a novel information-theoretic approach, based on von Neumann entropy, which provides a measure of information encoded in the networks at different scales. We also define a measure of distance between networks, based on information divergence, and optimal null models appropriate for the description of functional connectivity networks, to test for the presence of nontrivial structural patterns that are not the result of simple local constraints. This formalism enables a scale-resolved analysis of the distance between a functional connectivity network and its maximally random counterpart, thus providing a means to assess the effects of noise and image processing on network structure. We apply this novel approach to address a few open questions in the analysis of brain functional connectivity networks. Specifically, we demonstrate a strongly beneficial effect of network sparsification by removal of the weakest links, and the existence of an optimal threshold that maximizes the ability to extract information on large-scale network structures. Additionally, we investigate the effects of different degrees of motion at different scales, and compare the most popular processing pipelines designed to mitigate its deleterious effect on functional connectivity networks. We show that network sparsification, in combination with motion correction algorithms, dramatically improves detection of large scale network structure.
功能连接是源自大脑活动自发波动的区域间相关性,可以用具有连续(实值)边的完整图来表示。功能连接网络的结构受到去除运动、生理噪声和其他实验误差源影响的信号处理程序的强烈影响。然而,在没有既定事实的情况下,很难确定最佳的程序,也没有达成共识,即在不适当影响网络固有结构特征的情况下,去除干扰信号的最有效方法。在这里,我们使用一种新的基于冯·诺依曼熵的信息论方法,它提供了一种在不同尺度上对网络中编码信息的度量。我们还定义了一种基于信息散度的网络之间距离的度量,并定义了适合描述功能连接网络的最优空模型,以测试是否存在不是简单局部约束结果的非平凡结构模式。这种形式主义使我们能够对功能连接网络与其最大随机对应网络之间的距离进行分辨率分析,从而提供了一种评估噪声和图像处理对网络结构影响的方法。我们应用这种新方法来解决脑功能连接网络分析中的一些开放性问题。具体来说,我们证明了通过去除最弱的连接进行网络稀疏化具有很强的有益效果,并且存在一个最优阈值,可以最大程度地提取关于大规模网络结构的信息。此外,我们研究了不同尺度下不同程度的运动的影响,并比较了旨在减轻其对功能连接网络有害影响的最流行的处理管道。我们表明,网络稀疏化与运动校正算法相结合,可以极大地提高大规模网络结构的检测能力。