Department of Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences, SUNY Downstate Health Sciences University, School of Public Health, Brooklyn, NY, United States.
Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, College of Global Public Health, New York University, New York, NY, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2020 Feb 13;8(2):e14737. doi: 10.2196/14737.
The Text4baby (T4B) mobile health (mHealth) program is acclaimed to provide pregnant women with greater access to prenatal health care, resources, and information. However, little is known about whether urban African American and Afro-Caribbean immigrant pregnant women in the United States are receptive users of innovative health communication methods or of the cultural and systematic barriers that inhibit their behavioral intent to use T4B.
This study aimed to understand the lived experiences of urban African American and Afro-Caribbean immigrant pregnant women with accessing quality prenatal health care and health information; to assess usage of mHealth for seeking prenatal health information; and to measure changes in participants' knowledge, perceptions, and behavioral intent to use the T4B mHealth educational intervention.
An exploratory sequential mixed methods study was conducted among pregnant women and clinical professionals for a phenomenological exploration with focus groups, key informants, interviews, and observations. Qualitative themes were aligned with behavioral and information technology communications theoretical constructs to develop a survey instrument used. repeated-measures pre- and post-test design to evaluate changes in participants' knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs, of mHealth and T4B after a minimum of 4 weeks' exposure to the text message-based intervention. Triangulation and mixing of both qualitative and quantitative data occurred primarily during the survey development and also during final analysis.
A total of 9 women participated in phase 1, and 49 patients signed up for T4B and completed a 31-item survey at baseline and again during follow-up. Three themes were identified: (1) patient-provider engagement, (2) social support, and (3) acculturation. With time as a barrier to quality care, inadequate patient-provider engagement left participants feeling indifferent about the prenatal care and information they received in the clinical setting. Of 49 survey participants, 63% (31/49) strongly agreed that T4B would provide them with extra support during their pregnancy. On a Likert scale of 1 to 5, participants' perception of the usefulness of T4B ranked at 4.26, and their perception of the compatibility and relative advantage of using T4B ranked at 4.41 and 4.15, respectively. At follow-up, there was a 14% increase in participants reporting their intent to use T4B and a 28% increase from pretest and posttest in pregnant women strongly agreeing to speak more with their doctor about the information learned through T4B.
Urban African American and Afro-Caribbean immigrant pregnant women in Brooklyn endure a number of social and ecological determinants like low health literacy, income, and language that serve as barriers to accessing quality prenatal health care and information, which negatively impacts prenatal health behaviors and outcomes. Our study indicates a number of systematic, political, and other microsystem-level factors that perpetuate health inequities in our study population.
Text4baby(T4B)移动健康(mHealth)计划被誉为为孕妇提供更多的产前保健、资源和信息。然而,人们对美国城市非裔美国人和非裔加勒比移民孕妇是否接受创新的健康沟通方式,或者是否存在阻碍她们使用 T4B 的文化和系统障碍,知之甚少。
本研究旨在了解城市非裔美国人和非裔加勒比移民孕妇获得优质产前保健和健康信息的生活体验;评估 mHealth 在寻求产前健康信息方面的使用情况;并衡量参与者对 T4B mHealth 教育干预的知识、感知和行为意向的变化。
对孕妇和临床专业人员进行了一项探索性顺序混合方法研究,进行了现象学探索,包括焦点小组、主要知情人访谈、观察。定性主题与行为和信息技术通信理论结构一致,以开发出一个调查工具。使用重复测量的预-后测试设计,在至少 4 周的短信干预后,评估参与者对 mHealth 和 T4B 的知识、态度和信念的变化。定性和定量数据的三角测量和混合主要发生在调查开发过程中,也发生在最终分析中。
共有 9 名女性参加了第 1 阶段,49 名患者报名参加了 T4B,并在基线和随访期间完成了 31 项调查。确定了三个主题:(1)患者-提供者参与,(2)社会支持,和(3)文化适应。由于时间是获得高质量护理的障碍,患者-提供者参与不足使参与者对他们在临床环境中获得的产前护理和信息感到漠不关心。在 49 名调查参与者中,63%(31/49)强烈同意 T4B 将在他们怀孕期间为他们提供额外的支持。在 1 到 5 的李克特量表上,参与者对 T4B 的有用性的看法排名为 4.26,对使用 T4B 的兼容性和相对优势的看法分别排名为 4.41 和 4.15。在随访时,报告打算使用 T4B 的参与者增加了 14%,而孕妇强烈同意通过 T4B 与医生更多地讨论通过 T4B 学到的信息,这一比例从预测试和后测试分别增加了 28%。
布鲁克林的非裔美国人和非裔加勒比移民孕妇面临着许多社会和生态决定因素,如低健康素养、收入和语言,这些因素是获得优质产前保健和信息的障碍,这对产前健康行为和结果产生了负面影响。我们的研究表明,在我们的研究人群中存在许多系统的、政治的和其他微观系统层面的因素,这些因素使健康不平等持续存在。