Kamenska Natalia, Nabirova Dilyara, Davtyan Karapet, Davtyan Hayk, Zachariah Rony, Aslanyan Garry
Alliance for Public Health, Kyiv, Ukraine.
US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Central Asia Regional Office, Almaty, Kazakhstan.
J Infect Dev Ctries. 2019 Jul 31;13(7.1):89S-94S. doi: 10.3855/jidc.11294.
Ukraine has gaps in Tuberculosis (TB) service coverage, especially in key populations (KPs). We compared effectiveness of three different strategies for active TB detection among KPs and their linkage to TB treatment during three time periods.
The KPs included people who inject drugs (PWID), sex workers (SW), men who have sex with men (MSM) and groups at-risk of TB (ex-prisoners, Roma and homeless). The active case finding included decentralized symptom screening and specimen collection (2014, strategy-1), decentralized screening with patient referred for specimen collection (2015-2017, strategy-2) and strategy-2 plus GeneXpert (2018, strategy-3).
In total 680,760 KPs were screened, of whom 68% were PWID. TB case detection per 100,000 populations was 1,191 in strategy-1, 302 in strategy-2, and 235 in strategy-3. The number needed to screen (NNS) to identify one case was respectively 84, 332, and 425. TB detection was highest among homeless (range: 1,839-2,297 per 100,000 population). The lowest detection was among the MSM and SW. Between 2014 and 2018, 82-94% of all diagnosed TB patients in KPs started TB treatment.
The active case finding in KPs increased detection of TB cases in Ukraine, and the majority of diagnosed KPs initiated TB treatment. Centralization of diagnosis reduced the effectiveness of TB screening. Each region in Ukraine should assess the composition and the needs of KPs which will allow for adoption of specific strategies to detect TB among KPs with high TB prevalence.
乌克兰在结核病服务覆盖方面存在差距,尤其是在重点人群中。我们比较了三种不同策略在重点人群中进行活动性结核病检测及其在三个时间段与结核病治疗联系的有效性。
重点人群包括注射吸毒者、性工作者、男男性行为者以及结核病高危群体(刑满释放人员、罗姆人和无家可归者)。主动病例发现包括分散式症状筛查和标本采集(2014年,策略1)、分散式筛查并将患者转诊进行标本采集(2015 - 2017年,策略2)以及策略2加GeneXpert(2018年,策略3)。
总共筛查了680,760名重点人群,其中68%为注射吸毒者。每10万人口中的结核病病例检出数在策略1中为1,191例,策略2中为302例,策略3中为235例。识别一例病例所需的筛查人数(NNS)分别为84、332和425。无家可归者中的结核病检出率最高(范围:每10万人口1,839 - 2,297例)。男男性行为者和性工作者中的检出率最低。2014年至2018年期间,重点人群中所有确诊结核病患者的82 - 94%开始接受结核病治疗。
重点人群中的主动病例发现增加了乌克兰结核病病例的检出率,并且大多数确诊的重点人群开始接受结核病治疗。诊断集中化降低了结核病筛查的有效性。乌克兰的每个地区都应评估重点人群的构成和需求,这将有助于采用特定策略在结核病患病率高的重点人群中检测结核病。