University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK.
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.
Environ Monit Assess. 2020 Feb 21;192(3):195. doi: 10.1007/s10661-020-8153-1.
With air quality issues in urban areas garnering increasing media attention, concerned citizens are beginning to engage with the technology as a means of identifying and responding to the environmental risks posed. However, while much has been written about the accuracy of the units, little research has been conducted into its effects on users. As such, this research deploys coping theory to explore the specific ways in which portable air quality sensors influence user behaviour. This is done using a qualitative exploratory design, targeting parents and carers of children on the school run. Drawing from survey and interview responses, the article illustrates the decision-making pathways underpinning engagement with monitors and the ways in which they influence behaviour and disrupt misconceptions around air pollution. The study demonstrates that personal environmental monitors can play a role in protecting children from air pollution on the school run. They can raise awareness about air pollution and disrupt misconceptions about where does and does not occur. They can also encourage the public to change their behaviour in an attempt to mitigate and manage risks. However, the findings additionally reveal that sensor technology does not generate a simple binary response among users, of behavioural change or not. When attempts at behavioural change fail to reduce risk, resulting negative feelings can lead to inaction. Hence, the relationship between the technology and the individual is entwined with various social circumstances often beyond a parent or carer's control. Thus, top-down support aimed at tackling air pollution at source is essential if this bottom-up technology is to fulfil its full potential.
随着城市空气质量问题越来越受到媒体的关注,关注环境的市民开始使用这项技术来识别和应对环境风险。然而,尽管已经有很多关于这些设备准确性的研究,但对于它们对用户的影响却很少有研究。因此,本研究运用应对理论来探讨便携式空气质量传感器对用户行为的具体影响。本研究采用定性探索性设计,以接送孩子上学的家长和照顾者为目标。本文通过调查和访谈的回应,说明了与监测器互动的决策路径,以及它们如何影响行为和打破对空气污染的误解。研究表明,个人环境监测器可以在学校跑步时保护儿童免受空气污染的影响。它们可以提高人们对空气污染的认识,打破关于何处发生和不发生空气污染的误解。它们还可以鼓励公众改变行为,以减轻和管理风险。然而,研究结果还表明,传感器技术并没有在用户中产生简单的行为改变或不改变的二元反应。当行为改变的尝试未能降低风险时,由此产生的负面情绪可能导致无所作为。因此,技术与个人之间的关系与各种社会环境交织在一起,而这些社会环境往往超出了家长或照顾者的控制范围。因此,如果要充分发挥这种自下而上的技术的潜力,就必须从源头解决空气污染问题。