Bachman Pamela, Fischer Joshua, Song Zihong, Urbanczyk-Wochniak Ewa, Watson Greg
Science Organization, The Climate Corporation, Creve Coeur, MO, United States.
Regulatory Science, Bayer Crop Science, Chesterfield, MO, United States.
Front Plant Sci. 2020 Feb 6;11:21. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2020.00021. eCollection 2020.
Two primary use patterns exist for dsRNA-based products for crop protection: produced dsRNA such as in a genetically engineered (GE) crop; and topically applied dsRNA such as a spray application. To enable effective environmental risk assessments for these products, dsRNA must be successfully measured in relevant environmental compartments (soil, sediment, surface water) to provide information on potential exposure. This perspective reviews results from numerous environmental fate and degradation studies with topically applied unformulated dsRNAs to demonstrate the high lability of these molecules and low potential for persistence in the environment. Additionally, we report on results of a pilot study of topically applied dsRNA on soybean plants demonstrating similar rapid degradation under field conditions. Microbial degradation of nucleic acids in environmental compartments has been shown to be a key driver for this lack of persistence. In fact, the instability of dsRNA in the environment has posed a challenge for the development of commercial topically-applied products. Formulations or other approaches that mitigate environmental degradation may lead to development of commercially successful products but may change the known degradation kinetics of dsRNAs. The formulation of these products and the resultant impacts on the stability of the dsRNA in environmental compartments will need to be addressed using problem formulation and product formulation testing may be required on a case by case basis to ensure an effective risk assessment.
基于双链RNA(dsRNA)的作物保护产品存在两种主要使用模式:一种是在基因工程(GE)作物中产生的dsRNA;另一种是局部施用的dsRNA,如喷雾施用。为了对这些产品进行有效的环境风险评估,必须在相关环境介质(土壤、沉积物、地表水)中成功测量dsRNA,以提供潜在暴露信息。本观点综述了大量关于局部施用未配制dsRNA的环境归宿和降解研究结果,以证明这些分子的高不稳定性和在环境中低持久性的可能性。此外,我们报告了一项在大豆植株上局部施用dsRNA的试点研究结果,该研究表明在田间条件下dsRNA同样会快速降解。环境介质中核酸的微生物降解已被证明是导致这种缺乏持久性的关键因素。事实上,dsRNA在环境中的不稳定性对商业局部施用产品的开发构成了挑战。减轻环境降解的配方或其他方法可能会导致商业上成功的产品开发,但可能会改变dsRNA已知的降解动力学。这些产品的配方以及对环境介质中dsRNA稳定性的最终影响,需要通过问题制定来解决,并且可能需要逐案进行产品配方测试,以确保进行有效的风险评估。