Hettinger A Zachary, Benda Natalie, Roth Emilie, Hoffman Daniel, Iyer Akhila, Franklin Ella, Perry Shawna, Fairbanks R J, Bisantz Ann M
National Center for Human Factors in Healthcare, MedStar Health, Washington, DC; Department of Emergency Medicine, Georgetown University School of Medicine, Washington, DC.
National Center for Human Factors in Healthcare, MedStar Health, Washington, DC.
J Emerg Med. 2020 Apr;58(4):581-593. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2019.10.035. Epub 2020 Mar 5.
The current state of scientific knowledge regarding communication between emergency medicine (EM) providers indicates that communication is critical to safe and effective patient care.
In this study, we identified communication needs of EM nurses and physicians; in particular, what information should be conveyed, when, how, and to whom.
Five semi-structured focus groups and one interview were conducted with nine nurses, eight attending physicians, and four residents. Questions addressed how EM personnel use and share information about patients and clinical work, what information tends to be exchanged, and what additional information would be helpful to share. Sessions were audio recorded. Transcripts were generated and analyzed using a concept mapping approach (a visual qualitative analysis technique to represent and convey synthesized knowledge).
Eleven concept maps were produced summarizing: information physicians needed from nurses and vice versa; methods of communication that could be utilized; barriers or obstacles to effective communication; strategies to enhance or ensure effective communication; and environmental or situational factors that impact communication.
Our main finding of this research is that communication ensures shared awareness of patient health status, the care plan, status of plan steps and orders, and, especially, any critical changes or "surprises" regarding the health of a patient. Additionally, the research identified shared information needs; communication methods, strategies and barriers; and factors affecting successful communication, and has implications for both system and training design. Key implications for emergency nursing practice from this research are distilled in 10 'best practice' strategies for improving EM nurse-physician communication.
目前关于急诊医学(EM)提供者之间沟通的科学知识状况表明,沟通对于安全有效的患者护理至关重要。
在本研究中,我们确定了急诊护士和医生的沟通需求;特别是应该传达哪些信息、何时传达、如何传达以及传达给何人。
对9名护士、8名主治医生和4名住院医生进行了5个半结构化焦点小组讨论和1次访谈。问题涉及急诊人员如何使用和共享有关患者及临床工作的信息、倾向于交流哪些信息以及共享哪些额外信息会有所帮助。会议进行了录音。生成了文字记录,并使用概念图方法(一种用于表示和传达综合知识的视觉定性分析技术)进行分析。
制作了11个概念图,总结了:医生需要从护士那里获取的信息以及反之亦然;可以利用的沟通方法;有效沟通的障碍;增强或确保有效沟通的策略;以及影响沟通的环境或情境因素。
我们这项研究的主要发现是,沟通可确保对患者健康状况、护理计划、计划步骤和医嘱的状态,尤其是关于患者健康的任何关键变化或“意外情况”有共同的认识。此外,该研究确定了共同的信息需求、沟通方法、策略和障碍以及影响成功沟通的因素,并对系统和培训设计都有启示。本研究对急诊护理实践的关键启示提炼为10条改善急诊护士与医生沟通的“最佳实践”策略。