College of Natural Resources and Environment, Northwest A&F University, Yangling, 712100, China.
Key Laboratory of Plant Nutrition and the Agri-environment in Northwest China, Ministry of Agriculture, Yangling, 712100, China.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2020 May;27(15):18382-18391. doi: 10.1007/s11356-020-08322-1. Epub 2020 Mar 18.
Nitrate leaching is a main nitrogen (N) loss pathway in vegetable production. Although there are numerous mitigation practices that control nitrate leaching, an integrated assessment of these measures is lacking. Thus, we conducted a meta-analysis to integrate the assessment of strategies for controlling nitrate leaching from vegetable systems in China. The main strategies included improved N fertilizer management (INFM), reduced water management (RWM), comprehensive regulation of N fertilizer and water management (CFWM), and catch crops (CCs). Each mitigation measure decreased nitrate leaching significantly and did not reduce vegetable yields. CFWM reduced nitrate leaching the most at 41% on average, followed by CCs, RWM, and INFM (35%, 24%, and 22%, respectively). The nitrate leaching scaled yields (NLSY, defined as yield divided by the quantity of nitrate leaching) were significantly increased by 87%, 44%, 32%, and 27% for CFWM, CCs, INFM, and RWM, respectively. The efficacies of the strategies were dependent on soil properties. CFWM, INFM, and RWM were more effective in soils with low pH and coarse texture than in other soils. In conclusion, the risk of nitrate leaching from vegetable production systems is high, and INFM and CFWM are suggested to decrease nitrate leaching from vegetable production.
硝酸盐淋失是蔬菜生产中氮(N)损失的主要途径。尽管有许多缓解措施可以控制硝酸盐淋失,但缺乏对这些措施的综合评估。因此,我们进行了一项荟萃分析,以综合评估中国蔬菜系统控制硝酸盐淋失的策略。主要策略包括改进氮肥管理(INFM)、减少水分管理(RWM)、综合调控氮肥和水分管理(CFWM)和覆盖作物(CCs)。每种缓解措施都显著减少了硝酸盐淋失,但没有降低蔬菜产量。CFWM 平均减少硝酸盐淋失 41%,其次是 CCs、RWM 和 INFM(分别减少 35%、24%和 22%)。硝酸盐淋失标产量(NLSY,定义为产量除以硝酸盐淋失量)分别增加了 87%、44%、32%和 27%,CFWM、CCs、INFM 和 RWM 的分别增加了 87%、44%、32%和 27%。策略的效果取决于土壤性质。CFWM、INFM 和 RWM 在 pH 值低和质地粗的土壤中比在其他土壤中更有效。总之,蔬菜生产系统中硝酸盐淋失的风险很高,建议采用 INFM 和 CFWM 来减少蔬菜生产中的硝酸盐淋失。