Alkhadim Yara Khalid, Hulbah Malak Jameel, Nassar Hani Mohammad
Faculty of Dentistry, King Abdulaziz University, P. O. Box 80209, Jeddah 21589, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Restorative Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, King Abdulaziz University, P. O. Box 80209, Jeddah 21589, Saudi Arabia.
Materials (Basel). 2020 Mar 18;13(6):1376. doi: 10.3390/ma13061376.
The aim of this study was to compare color shift, color stability, and post-polishing surface roughness of esthetic restorative materials. Twenty-five disc-shaped specimens (10 mm in diameter and 2 mm in thickness) from five esthetic resin materials (Z250XT, IPS Empress-Direct, G-ænial, Vit-l-escence, and Ceram.X) were fabricated. Color shift before and immediately after light-curing (∆E) then color stability after immersion in tea, coffee, berry juice, and distilled water were measured using a spectrophotometer. Color changes were measured after 2 (ΔE), 4 (ΔE), 6 (ΔE), and 8 weeks (ΔE). Surface roughness values (Rq) were determined using an optical profilometer after polishing using a rotary polishing system. Data were analyzed using ANOVA and multiple comparison methods at 0.05 significance level. There were no significant differences between the tested materials regarding color shift except between Vit-l-escence and Ceram.X ( = 0.033). There was no significant difference between coffee and tea solutions ( = 1.0) and between berry juice and distilled water ( = 0.15). There was no difference between the tested materials regarding Rq ( = 0.057). Ceram.X was associated with the lowest ΔE values overall. Tested materials were comparable regarding color shift and post-polishing surface roughness. Susceptibility to staining was dependent on the material.
本研究的目的是比较美学修复材料的颜色变化、颜色稳定性和抛光后表面粗糙度。制备了来自五种美学树脂材料(Z250XT、IPS Empress-Direct、G-ænial、Vit-l-escence和Ceram.X)的25个圆盘形试样(直径10毫米,厚度2毫米)。使用分光光度计测量光固化前和光固化后立即的颜色变化(ΔE),然后测量浸泡在茶、咖啡、浆果汁和蒸馏水中后的颜色稳定性。在2周(ΔE)、4周(ΔE)、6周(ΔE)和8周(ΔE)后测量颜色变化。使用旋转抛光系统抛光后,使用光学轮廓仪测定表面粗糙度值(Rq)。在0.05显著性水平下,使用方差分析和多重比较方法分析数据。除了Vit-l-escence和Ceram.X之间(P = 0.033),测试材料在颜色变化方面没有显著差异。咖啡和茶溶液之间(P = 1.0)以及浆果汁和蒸馏水之间(P = 0.15)没有显著差异。测试材料在Rq方面没有差异(P = 0.057)。总体而言,Ceram.X的ΔE值最低。测试材料在颜色变化和抛光后表面粗糙度方面具有可比性。染色敏感性取决于材料。