Department of Internal Medicine, Hospital Vall d'Hebron, Barcelona, Spain.
Department of Internal Medicine, Hospital General Universitario de Elche, Elche, Spain.
Curr Med Res Opin. 2020 Jun;36(6):1033-1042. doi: 10.1080/03007995.2020.1749995. Epub 2020 Apr 17.
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is one of the diseases that leads to a higher number of hospitalizations in internal medicine departments. These patients are usually older and have greater multimorbidity than COPD patients hospitalized in other departments, which hinders the implementation of clinical guidelines necessarily focused on the management of a single disease. To ascertain the opinion of Spanish internists on the management of COPD in scenarios in which the available evidence is sparse and to produce a consensus document designed to assist in decision-making in COPD patients with comorbidities treated in internal medicine services. After identifying the clinical areas of greatest uncertainty by consensus, a survey was designed with 89 questions on the epidemiology and diagnosis of COPD, its management both in stable phase and during decompensation, and the treatment of the associated comorbidities in outpatients and inpatients. The consensus process was carried out using the Delphi method in an anonymized two-round process. The survey was completed by 67 internists experienced in the clinical management of COPD. Of all the questions posed, a consensus was reached for 51 (57.3%) in the first round and for 67 (75.3%) in the second round. The result of the process is a series of 67 suggestions that may assist in the care of these patients. Our study allows us to ascertain the views of a large number of internists experienced in the management of COPD and to learn how the recommendations for guidelines are applied in clinical practice.
慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)是导致内科住院人数增加的疾病之一。这些患者通常年龄较大,合并症多于其他科室住院的 COPD 患者,这阻碍了针对单一疾病管理的临床指南的实施。为了确定西班牙内科医生对 COPD 管理的看法,这些看法是基于现有证据稀疏的情况下,并制定一份共识文件,旨在协助内科医生治疗合并症的 COPD 患者的决策。在通过共识确定了最大不确定性的临床领域后,设计了一项调查,共 89 个问题,涉及 COPD 的流行病学和诊断、稳定期和失代偿期的管理,以及门诊和住院患者合并症的治疗。共识过程使用 Delphi 方法在匿名的两轮过程中进行。这项调查由 67 名具有 COPD 临床管理经验的内科医生完成。在提出的所有问题中,第一轮有 51 项(57.3%)达成共识,第二轮有 67 项(75.3%)达成共识。这一过程的结果是一系列 67 条建议,可能有助于这些患者的护理。我们的研究使我们能够了解大量具有 COPD 管理经验的内科医生的观点,并了解指南建议在临床实践中的应用情况。