ACTA - les instituts techniques agricoles, 149 rue de Bercy, Paris cedex 12, 75595, France.
Université Paris-Saclay, AgroParisTech, INRAE, UMR Agronomie, 78850, Thiverval-Grignon, France.
Sci Rep. 2020 Apr 14;10(1):6404. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-62954-4.
Downy mildew is a severe disease of grapevines treated by repeated fungicide applications during the growing season. The impact of these treatments on human health is currently under scrutiny. Fungicide application long before disease onset is not thought to be greatly beneficial for grape production, but the first fungicide treatment is applied at least six weeks before disease onset in more than 50% of the vineyards in the Bordeaux region, a major French vine-growing area. We estimate that applying one fungicide every two weeks at disease onset would reduce fungicide applications against downy mildew by 56% (95%IC = [51.0%, 61.3%]), on average, relative to current levels. This decrease is slightly greater than the level of exposure reduction resulting from the random suppression of one out of every two fungicide treatments (i.e. 50%). The reduction is lower when treatments are sprayed weekly but still reaches at least 12.4% (95%IC = [4.3%, 20.8%]) in this case. We show that this and other strategies reducing the number of treatments would decrease operator exposure to pesticides as effectively as the use of various types of personal protective equipments in the Bordeaux region. The implementation of this strategy would significantly decrease fungicide use, health risks, and adverse environmental impacts of vineyards.
霜霉病是一种严重的葡萄藤病害,在生长季节需要反复使用杀菌剂进行治疗。这些处理方法对人类健康的影响目前正在受到审查。在疾病发生之前很久就进行杀菌剂处理,据认为对葡萄生产并没有很大的益处,但在波尔多地区(法国主要的葡萄种植区),超过 50%的葡萄园至少在疾病发生前六周就开始第一次杀菌剂处理。我们估计,在疾病发生时每两周使用一次杀菌剂,平均而言,相对于当前水平,可以减少 56%(95%CI=[51.0%,61.3%])的霜霉病防治用杀菌剂的使用。与随机抑制每两次杀菌剂处理中的一次(即 50%)相比,这种减少略高于暴露减少的水平。当每周喷洒处理时,减少量较低,但在这种情况下仍至少达到 12.4%(95%CI=[4.3%,20.8%])。我们表明,这种和其他减少处理次数的策略可以像在波尔多地区使用各种类型的个人防护设备一样有效地降低操作人员接触农药的风险。实施这一策略将显著减少杀菌剂的使用、葡萄园的健康风险和对环境的不利影响。