Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, University of Catania, Viale A. Doria, 6, 95125 Catania, Italy.
Center of Excellence for the Acceleration of Harm Reduction, University of Catania, Via Santa Sofia 89, 95123 Catania, Italy.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Apr 10;17(7):2614. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17072614.
Mobile health technologies are being developed for personal lifestyle and medical healthcare support, of which a growing number are designed to assist smokers to quit. The potential impact of these technologies in the fight against smoking addiction and on improving quitting rates must be systematically evaluated. The aim of this report is to identify and appraise the most promising smoking detection and quitting technologies (e.g., smartphone apps, wearable devices) supporting smoking reduction or quitting programs. We searched PubMed and Scopus databases (2008-2019) for studies on mobile health technologies developed to assist smokers to quit using a combination of Medical Subject Headings topics and free text terms. A Google search was also performed to retrieve the most relevant smartphone apps for quitting smoking, considering the average user's rating and the ranking computed by the search engine algorithms. All included studies were evaluated using consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research, such as applied methodologies and the performed evaluation protocol. Main outcome measures were usability and effectiveness of smoking detection and quitting technologies supporting smoking reduction or quitting programs. Our search identified 32 smoking detection and quitting technologies (12 smoking detection systems and 20 smoking quitting smartphone apps). Most of the existing apps for quitting smoking require the users to register every smoking event. Moreover, only a restricted group of them have been scientifically evaluated. The works supported by documented experimental evaluation show very high detection scores, however the experimental protocols usually lack in variability (e.g., only right-hand patients, not natural sequence of gestures) and have been conducted with limited numbers of patients as well as under constrained settings quite far from real-life use scenarios. Several recent scientific works show very promising results but, at the same time, present obstacles for the application on real-life daily scenarios.
移动健康技术正在被开发用于个人生活方式和医疗保健支持,其中越来越多的技术旨在帮助吸烟者戒烟。这些技术在对抗吸烟成瘾和提高戒烟率方面的潜在影响必须进行系统评估。本报告的目的是确定和评估最有前途的吸烟检测和戒烟技术(例如,智能手机应用程序、可穿戴设备),以支持减少吸烟或戒烟计划。我们在 PubMed 和 Scopus 数据库(2008-2019 年)中搜索了使用医学主题词和自由文本术语组合开发的用于帮助吸烟者戒烟的移动健康技术研究。还进行了 Google 搜索,以检索最相关的智能手机戒烟应用程序,考虑到平均用户的评分和搜索引擎算法计算的排名。所有纳入的研究均使用定性研究报告的统一标准进行评估,例如应用方法和执行的评估方案。主要结果测量是支持减少吸烟或戒烟计划的吸烟检测和戒烟技术的可用性和有效性。我们的搜索确定了 32 种吸烟检测和戒烟技术(12 种吸烟检测系统和 20 种戒烟智能手机应用程序)。大多数现有的戒烟应用程序要求用户记录每一次吸烟事件。此外,只有少数应用程序经过了科学评估。有文件记录的实验评估支持的工作显示出非常高的检测分数,但是实验方案通常缺乏变异性(例如,仅右手患者,而不是自然手势序列),并且仅在有限数量的患者以及在与现实生活使用场景相差甚远的受限环境中进行了研究。最近的一些科学工作显示出非常有前途的结果,但同时也为在现实生活日常场景中的应用带来了障碍。