Oklahoma Tobacco Research Center, Stephenson Cancer Center, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, OK, United States.
Moffitt Cancer Center, Tampa, FL, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2020 Apr 15;8(4):e15960. doi: 10.2196/15960.
Socioeconomic disadvantage is associated with a reduced likelihood of smoking cessation. Smartphone ownership is increasing rapidly, including among low-income adults, and smartphone interventions for smoking cessation may increase access to smoking cessation treatment among socioeconomically disadvantaged adults.
This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility of an automated smartphone-based approach to delivering financial incentives for smoking cessation.
Socioeconomically disadvantaged adults initiating tobacco cessation treatment were followed from 1 week before a scheduled quit attempt through 26 weeks after the quit date. Participants received telephone counseling and nicotine replacement therapy. Smoking cessation was verified 5 times per week via smartphone prompts to self-report smoking status and submit a breath sample via a portable carbon monoxide (CO) monitor that was connected with participants' smartphones. Identity was verified during smoking status assessments using smartphone-based facial recognition software. When smoking abstinence and identity were verified, an automated credit card payment was triggered. Participants were incentivized for abstinence on the quit date and up to five days per week during the first 4 weeks after the scheduled quit date, with additional incentives offered during postquit weeks 8 and 12. In total, participants had the opportunity to earn up to US $250 in abstinence-contingent incentives over the first 12 weeks of the quit attempt.
Participants (N=16) were predominantly female (12/16, 75%) and non-Hispanic white (11/16, 69%), black (4/16, 25%), or Hispanic of any race (1/16, 6%). Most participants (9/16, 56%) reported an annual household income of <US $11,000. During the first 4 weeks after the scheduled quit date, participants completed a median of 16 (out of 21; range 1-21) mobile smoking status assessments, and they earned a median of US $28 in abstinence-contingent incentives (out of a possible US $150; range US $0-US $135). Median earnings did not change during the 8- and 12-week incentivized follow-up periods (total median earnings over 12 weeks=US $28; range US $0-US $167). During the first 4 weeks after the scheduled quit date, participants abstained from smoking on a median of 5 (out of 21) assessment days (range 0-20). At the in-person follow-up visits, the expired CO-confirmed 7-day point prevalence abstinence rates were 19% (3/16) and 13% (2/16) at 12 and 26 weeks postquit, respectively. Overall, most participants reported that the system was easy to use and that they would recommend this treatment to their friends and family.
Preliminary data suggest that this smartphone-based approach to verifying identity and smoking status and automating the delivery of abstinence-contingent incentives to a credit card is feasible for use among socioeconomically disadvantaged adults. However, continued refinement is warranted.
社会经济地位低下与戒烟成功率降低有关。智能手机的拥有率正在迅速增长,包括低收入成年人在内,而针对戒烟的智能手机干预措施可能会增加社会经济地位低下的成年人获得戒烟治疗的机会。
本研究旨在评估一种基于自动化智能手机的方法来提供戒烟经济奖励的可行性。
从计划戒烟前 1 周开始,对社会经济地位低下的成年吸烟者进行随访,直至戒烟日期后 26 周。参与者接受电话咨询和尼古丁替代疗法。通过智能手机提示,每周 5 次验证戒烟情况,并通过与参与者智能手机相连的便携式一氧化碳(CO)监测器提交呼吸样本。在吸烟状况评估期间,通过基于智能手机的面部识别软件验证身份。当吸烟状况和身份得到验证后,将自动触发信用卡支付。参与者在戒烟日以及在计划戒烟日期后的前 4 周内每周最多可获得 5 天的戒烟奖励,在戒烟后第 8 周和第 12 周还可获得额外奖励。在戒烟尝试的前 12 周内,参与者最多有机会获得高达 250 美元的戒烟奖励。
参与者(N=16)主要为女性(12/16,75%)和非西班牙裔白人(11/16,69%)、黑人(4/16,25%)或任何种族的西班牙裔(1/16,6%)。大多数参与者(9/16,56%)报告家庭年收入低于 11000 美元。在计划戒烟后的前 4 周内,参与者完成了中位数为 16 次(21 次中的;范围 1-21)移动吸烟状况评估,他们获得了中位数为 28 美元的戒烟奖励(可能为 150 美元;范围 0-135 美元)。在 8 周和 12 周的激励性随访期间,中位数收入没有变化(12 周内的中位数收入为 28 美元;范围为 0-167 美元)。在计划戒烟后的前 4 周内,参与者在中位数为 5 天(21 天中的;范围为 0-20 天)的评估日中没有吸烟。在面对面随访中,12 周和 26 周时,呼气 CO 确认的 7 天点患病率分别为 19%(3/16)和 13%(2/16)。总体而言,大多数参与者表示该系统易于使用,并且他们会将这种治疗方法推荐给他们的朋友和家人。
初步数据表明,这种基于智能手机的身份验证和吸烟状态验证方法以及自动向信用卡发放戒烟奖励是可行的,可以用于社会经济地位低下的成年人。但是,需要进一步改进。