Baalman Sarah W E, Schroevers Florian E, Oakley Abel J, Brouwer Tom F, van der Stuijt Willeke, Bleijendaal Hidde, Ramos Lucas A, Lopes Ricardo R, Marquering Henk A, Knops Reinoud E, de Groot Joris R
Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Heart Center, Department of Clinical and Experimental Cardiology, Amsterdam Cardiovascular Sciences, Meibergdreef 9, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Amsterdam University of Amsterdam, Faculty of Science, Science Park 904, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Int J Cardiol. 2020 Oct 1;316:130-136. doi: 10.1016/j.ijcard.2020.04.046. Epub 2020 Apr 18.
Deep learning (DL) has shown promising results in improving atrial fibrillation (AF) detection algorithms. However, these models are often criticized because of their "black box" nature.
To develop a morphology based DL model to discriminate AF from sinus rhythm (SR), and to visualize which parts of the ECG are used by the model to derive to the right classification.
We pre-processed raw data of 1469 ECGs in AF or SR, of patients with a history AF. Input data was generated by normalizing all single cycles (SC) of one ECG lead to SC-ECG samples by 1) centralizing the R wave or 2) scaling from R-to- R wave. Different DL models were trained by splitting the data in a training, validation and test set. By using a DL based heat mapping technique we visualized those areas of the ECG used by the classifier to come to the correct classification.
The DL model with the best performance was a feedforward neural network trained by SC-ECG samples on a R-to-R wave basis of lead II, resulting in an accuracy of 0.96 and F1-score of 0.94. The onset of the QRS complex proved to be the most relevant area for the model to discriminate AF from SR.
The morphology based DL model developed in this study was able to discriminate AF from SR with a very high accuracy. DL model visualization may help clinicians gain insights into which (unrecognized) ECG features are most sensitive to discriminate AF from SR.
深度学习(DL)在改进房颤(AF)检测算法方面已显示出有前景的结果。然而,这些模型因其“黑箱”性质常受到批评。
开发一种基于形态学的深度学习模型,以区分房颤与窦性心律(SR),并可视化该模型用于得出正确分类的心电图的哪些部分。
我们对1469例有房颤病史患者的房颤或窦性心律心电图原始数据进行了预处理。通过将一个心电图导联的所有单周期(SC)按以下方式归一化为SC - 心电图样本生成输入数据:1)使R波居中或2)从R波到R波进行缩放。通过将数据划分为训练集、验证集和测试集来训练不同的深度学习模型。通过使用基于深度学习的热图技术,我们可视化了分类器用于得出正确分类的心电图区域。
性能最佳的深度学习模型是一个前馈神经网络,它基于II导联的R波到R波的SC - 心电图样本进行训练,准确率为0.96,F1分数为0.94。事实证明,QRS波群的起始部分是该模型区分房颤与窦性心律最相关的区域。
本研究中开发的基于形态学的深度学习模型能够以非常高的准确率区分房颤与窦性心律。深度学习模型可视化可能有助于临床医生深入了解哪些(未被识别的)心电图特征对区分房颤与窦性心律最敏感。