Nutrition, Food Science and Gastronomy Department-XaRTA, Torribera Food Science Campus, Faculty of Pharmacy and Food Science, Universitat de Barcelona, Av. Prat de la Riba, 171, 08921, Santa Coloma de Gramenet, Spain.
Institut de Recerca en Nutrició i Seguretat Alimentària, Universitat de Barcelona, Av. Prat de la Riba, 171, 08921, Santa Coloma de Gramenet, Spain.
Plant Foods Hum Nutr. 2020 Sep;75(3):344-354. doi: 10.1007/s11130-020-00828-w.
The objective is to verify if gluten-free (GF) and gluten-containing (G) breads differ in their sodium content and lipid profile. Samples of GF (n = 20) and G (n = 14) sliced white sandwich bread of commercial brands most frequently consumed in Spain were collected. The fatty acid (FA) composition and the contents of sodium, fat, cholesterol and phytosterols were determined. Sodium, fat and cholesterol contents were significantly higher in GF bread. The FA composition also differed, while G breads declared in most instances the use of sunflower oil as fat ingredient and presented a higher polyunsaturated FA percentage; GF breads declared a wide variety of fats and oils as ingredients (coconut, palm, olive, sunflower, etc.) which was reflected in their FA profile. Cholesterol content was higher in GF bread because five samples declared the use of whole egg, while G samples did not include any egg product in their formulas. Phytosterol content was higher in G bread but its variability was greater in GF bread. In conclusion, nutritional quality of GF bread varied depending on the ingredients used and might be lower than that of G bread. However, these differences in composition could be reduced or eliminated through changes in the formulation of GF bread. Moreover, the comparison of the results obtained in our laboratory for fat and salt content with the declared contents on the labels showed a much higher deviation for GF samples and it can be concluded that the quality of the nutritional information declared was lower in GF samples.
目的是验证无麸质(GF)和含麸质(G)面包在钠含量和脂质谱方面是否存在差异。收集了西班牙最常食用的商业品牌的 GF(n=20)和 G(n=14)切片白三明治面包样品。测定了脂肪酸(FA)组成以及钠、脂肪、胆固醇和植物甾醇的含量。GF 面包的钠、脂肪和胆固醇含量明显较高。FA 组成也存在差异,而 G 面包在大多数情况下宣称使用葵花籽油作为脂肪成分,并且具有更高的多不饱和 FA 百分比;GF 面包宣称使用多种脂肪和油作为成分(椰子、棕榈、橄榄油、葵花籽油等),这反映在其 FA 谱中。GF 面包中的胆固醇含量较高,因为有五个样品宣称使用全蛋,而 G 样品在其配方中不包括任何鸡蛋产品。G 面包中的植物甾醇含量较高,但 GF 面包中的变异性更大。总之,GF 面包的营养质量因所用成分而异,可能低于 G 面包。然而,通过改变 GF 面包的配方,可以减少或消除这些成分差异。此外,我们实验室对脂肪和盐含量的结果与标签上宣称的含量进行比较,发现 GF 样品的偏差要大得多,可以得出结论,GF 样品宣称的营养信息质量较低。