Pediatric Department, Ospedale Buzzi, Università di Milano, Italy.
Gastroenterology and Hepatology Pediatric Department, Università La Sapienza, Roma; Italy.
Dig Liver Dis. 2020 Sep;52(9):1011-1016. doi: 10.1016/j.dld.2020.05.001. Epub 2020 Jun 15.
to investigate the reliability of laryngeal reflux finding score (RFS) and symptom index (RSI) in assessing gastroesophageal reflux (GER) in children and infants.
patients with laryngeal or respiratory symptoms, who underwent laryngoscopy and esophageal pH-impedance (MII-pH) were recruited. RSI and RFS were correlated to MII-pH results. A RSI>13, RFS>7, acid exposure index>7%, total reflux episodes>100/24 h in infants or>70/24 h in children, or a positive symptom index or association probability, were considered pathological. Analysis considering age (</>12 months) was performed. Sensitivity, specificity, positive (PPV) and negative predictive values (NPV) of the laryngeal scores were calculated.
197 children (median 53 months, 61 infants) were enrolled. MII-pH was pathological in 5/10 patients with RFS>7, and in 17/31 with RSI>13. RFS>7 had 3.9% sensitivity, 93% specificity, a PPV of 50 and a NPV of 34 in predicting GER disease. RFS was inversely associated to weakly acidic and proximal GER. RSI>13 had 13% sensitivity, 83% specificity, and a PPV and NPV similar to RFS. RSI was significantly associated with the number of acid reflux episodes, and, in infants, with bolus exposure index.
RSI and RFS aren't accurate in predicting GER in infants and children. Acid reflux relates to laryngeal symptoms, but neither acid, nor proximal and weakly acidic GER relate to laryngeal alterations.
探讨喉反流发现评分(RFS)和症状指数(RSI)在评估儿童和婴儿胃食管反流(GER)中的可靠性。
招募有喉或呼吸症状并接受喉镜和食管 pH 阻抗(MII-pH)检查的患者。将 RSI 和 RFS 与 MII-pH 结果相关联。RSI>13、RFS>7、酸暴露指数>7%、婴儿总反流次数>100/24 小时或儿童>70/24 小时、或阳性症状指数或关联概率被认为是病理性的。进行了考虑年龄(</>12 个月)的分析。计算了喉评分的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值(PPV)和阴性预测值(NPV)。
共纳入 197 名儿童(中位数 53 个月,61 名婴儿)。在 RFS>7 的 10 例患者中有 5 例 MII-pH 病理性,在 RSI>13 的 31 例患者中有 17 例 MII-pH 病理性。RFS>7 的敏感性为 3.9%,特异性为 93%,PPV 为 50%,NPV 为 34%,预测 GER 疾病的准确性较低。RFS 与弱酸性和近端 GER 呈负相关。RSI>13 的敏感性为 13%,特异性为 83%,PPV 和 NPV 与 RFS 相似。RSI 与酸反流次数显著相关,在婴儿中与食团暴露指数相关。
RSI 和 RFS 不能准确预测婴儿和儿童的 GER。酸反流与喉症状有关,但无论是酸反流、近端 GER 还是弱酸性 GER 均与喉改变无关。