Biomechanical investigation of the effect of pedicle-based hybrid stabilization constructs: A finite element study.

Hybrid stabilization is widely performed for the surgical treatment of degenerative disk diseases. Pedicle-based hybrid stabilization intends to reduce fusion-associated drawbacks of adjacent segment degeneration, construct failure, and pseudoarthrosis. Recently, many types of pedicle-based hybrid stabilization systems have been developed and optimized, using polymeric devices as an adjunct for lumbar fusion procedures. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of new pedicle-based hybrid stabilization on bending stiffness and center of rotation at operated and adjacent levels in comparison with established semirigid and rigid devices in lumbar fusion procedures. A validated three-dimensional finite element model of the L3-S1 segments was modified to simulate postoperative changes during combined loading (moment of 7.5 N m + follower load of 400 N). Two models instrumented with pedicle-based hybrid stabilization (Dynesys Transition Optima, NFlex), semirigid system (polyetheretherketone), and rigid fixation system (titanium rod (Ti) were compared with those of the healthy and degenerated models. Contact force on the facet joint during extension increased in fusion (40 N) with an increase of bending stiffness in Dynesys and NFlex. The center of rotation shifted in posterior and cranial directions of the fused level. The centers of rotation in the lower lumbar spine is segment dependent and altered with the adopted construct. The bending stiffness was varied from 1.47 N m/° in lateral bending for the healthy model to 5.75 N m/° for the NFlex stabilization, which had the closest center of rotation, compared to the healthy center of rotation. Locations of center of rotation, stress, and strain distribution varied according to construct design and materials used. These data could help understand the biomechanical effects of current pedicle-based hybrid stabilization on the behavior of the lower lumbar spine.