Kumar Sujay V, Dirmeyer Paul A, Peters-Lidard Christa D, Bindlish Rajat, Bolten John
Hydrological Sciences Laboratory, NASA GSFC, Greenbelt, MD.
George Mason University, Fairfax, VA.
Remote Sens Environ. 2018 Jan;204:392-400. doi: 10.1016/j.rse.2017.10.016. Epub 2017 Oct 21.
Microwave radiometry has a long legacy of providing estimates of remotely sensed near surface soil moisture measurements over continental and global scales. A consistent assessment of the errors and uncertainties associated with these retrievals is important for their effective utilization in modeling, data assimilation and end-use application environments. This article presents an evaluation of soil moisture retrieval products from AMSR-E, ASCAT, SMOS, AMSR2 and SMAP instruments using information theory-based metrics. These metrics rely on time series analysis of soil moisture retrievals for estimating the measurement error, level of randomness (entropy) and regularity (complexity) of the data. The results of the study indicate that the measurement errors in the remote sensing retrievals are significantly larger than that of the ground soil moisture measurements. The SMAP retrievals, on the other hand, were found to have reduced errors (comparable to those of in-situ datasets), particularly over areas with moderate vegetation. The SMAP retrievals also demonstrate high information content relative to other retrieval products, with higher levels of complexity and reduced entropy. Finally, a joint evaluation of the entropy and complexity of remotely sensed soil moisture products indicates that the information content of the AMSR-E, ASCAT, SMOS and AMSR2 retrievals is low, whereas SMAP retrievals show better performance. The use of information theoretic assessments is effective in quantifying the required levels of improvements needed in the remote sensing soil moisture retrievals to enhance their utility and information content.
微波辐射测量法在提供大陆和全球尺度上近地表土壤湿度遥感测量估计值方面有着悠久的历史。对与这些反演相关的误差和不确定性进行一致评估,对于它们在建模、数据同化和最终应用环境中的有效利用至关重要。本文使用基于信息论的指标对来自先进微波扫描辐射计 - E(AMSR - E)、先进散射计(ASCAT)、土壤湿度和海洋盐度探测仪(SMOS)、先进微波扫描辐射计2(AMSR2)和土壤湿度主动被动遥感卫星(SMAP)仪器的土壤湿度反演产品进行了评估。这些指标依赖于土壤湿度反演的时间序列分析,以估计测量误差、数据的随机性水平(熵)和规律性(复杂性)。研究结果表明,遥感反演中的测量误差明显大于地面土壤湿度测量误差。另一方面,发现SMAP反演的误差有所降低(与原位数据集相当),特别是在植被适中的地区。相对于其他反演产品,SMAP反演还显示出高信息含量,具有更高的复杂性水平和更低的熵。最后,对遥感土壤湿度产品的熵和复杂性进行联合评估表明,AMSR - E、ASCAT、SMOS和AMSR2反演的信息含量较低,而SMAP反演表现更好。使用信息论评估有效地量化了遥感土壤湿度反演中提高其效用和信息含量所需的改进水平。