Department of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2020 Jul 20;63(7):2229-2244. doi: 10.1044/2020_JSLHR-20-00027. Epub 2020 Jul 8.
Purpose This study compared performance on the Syllable Repetition Task (SRT) by preschoolers with diverse speech and language abilities to identify underlying impairments in speech processes. Method Three groups of 13 children ages 4 and 5 years with (a) typically developing (TD) speech and language, (b) speech sound disorder (SSD), and (c) comorbid developmental language disorder and speech sound disorder (DLD + SSD) completed the SRT. We calculated competence, memory, encoding, and transcoding scores, as well as word-initial stress pattern and vowel accuracy. Results A 3 × 3 (Group × Syllable length) factorial multivariate analysis of covariance revealed group differences for all measures and syllable length differences for memory, transcoding, and competence. There were no interactions between group and syllable length. TD children obtained the highest scores on each measure, though children with DLD + SSD performed similarly to TD children on encoding when vocabulary was included as a covariate. Children with SSD only outperformed children with DLD + SSD on competence and transcoding, and these two groups performed similarly on memory. A separate exploratory analysis using a 3 × 3 multivariate analysis of covariance revealed that children with DLD + SSD were more likely than children in the other groups to produce weak word-initial stress and vowel errors during syllable repetition. Conclusion Children with SSD and DLD + SSD exhibit underlying phonological deficits on the SRT compared to TD children. Results support the claim that memory and encoding are deficits in SSD. In addition, transcoding deficits were identified among children with no known oromotor impairment. Therefore, more research is required to identify the relationship between SRT performance and explicit measures of phonological processing.
本研究通过比较不同言语语言能力的学龄前儿童在音节重复任务(SRT)上的表现,以确定言语过程中的潜在损伤。
三组年龄在 4 岁和 5 岁之间的儿童,分别为(a)言语语言发育正常(TD)、(b)言语语音障碍(SSD)和(c)发育性语言障碍合并言语语音障碍(DLD+SSD),完成了 SRT。我们计算了能力、记忆、编码和转码分数,以及词首重音模式和元音准确性。
3×3(组×音节长度)的多变量协方差分析显示,所有指标上都存在组间差异,记忆、转码和能力上存在音节长度差异。组间和音节长度之间没有相互作用。TD 儿童在每个指标上的得分最高,尽管当词汇量作为协变量时,具有 DLD+SSD 的儿童在编码上的表现与 TD 儿童相似。仅具有 SSD 的儿童在能力和转码方面优于具有 DLD+SSD 的儿童,而这两组在记忆方面表现相似。使用 3×3 的多变量协方差分析的单独探索性分析表明,与其他组相比,具有 DLD+SSD 的儿童在音节重复时更有可能产生弱词首重音和元音错误。
与 TD 儿童相比,具有 SSD 和 DLD+SSD 的儿童在 SRT 上表现出潜在的语音缺陷。结果支持记忆和编码是 SSD 缺陷的说法。此外,在没有已知口运动障碍的儿童中也发现了转码缺陷。因此,需要更多的研究来确定 SRT 表现与语音处理的显式测量之间的关系。