School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
School of Biological Sciences, The University of Queensland, St. Lucia, Qld, Australia.
Glob Chang Biol. 2020 Oct;26(10):5816-5828. doi: 10.1111/gcb.15272. Epub 2020 Aug 8.
Ecosystems are being altered by rapid and interacting changes in natural processes and anthropogenic threats to biodiversity. Uncertainty in historical, current and future effectiveness of actions hampers decisions about how to mitigate changes to prevent biodiversity loss and species extinctions. Research in resource management, agriculture and health indicates that forecasts predicting the effects of near-term or seasonal environmental conditions on management greatly improve outcomes. Such forecasts help resolve uncertainties about when and how to operationalize management. We reviewed the scientific literature on environmental management to investigate whether near-term forecasts are developed to inform biodiversity decisions in Australia, a nation with one of the highest recent extinction rates across the globe. We found that forecasts focused on economic objectives (e.g. fisheries management) predict on significantly shorter timelines and answer a broader range of management questions than forecasts focused on biodiversity conservation. We then evaluated scientific literature on the effectiveness of 484 actions to manage seven major terrestrial threats in Australia, to identify opportunities for near-term forecasts to inform operational conservation decisions. Depending on the action, between 30% and 80% threat management operations experienced near-term weather impacts on outcomes before, during or after management. Disease control, species translocation/reintroduction and habitat restoration actions were most frequently impacted, and negative impacts such as increased species mortality and reduced recruitment were more likely than positive impacts. Drought or dry conditions, and rainfall, were the most frequently reported weather impacts, indicating that near-term forecasts predicting the effects of low or excessive rainfall on management outcomes are likely to have the greatest benefits. Across the world, many regions are, like Australia, becoming warmer and drier, or experiencing more extreme rainfall events. Informing conservation decisions with near-term and seasonal ecological forecasting will be critical to harness uncertainties and lower the risk of threat management failure under global change.
生态系统正在受到自然过程的快速和相互作用的变化以及生物多样性面临的人为威胁的影响。历史、当前和未来行动的有效性的不确定性阻碍了关于如何减轻变化以防止生物多样性丧失和物种灭绝的决策。资源管理、农业和卫生方面的研究表明,预测近期或季节性环境条件对管理的影响可以极大地改善结果。这些预测有助于解决关于何时以及如何实施管理的不确定性。我们审查了环境管理方面的科学文献,以调查澳大利亚是否制定了近期预测来为生物多样性决策提供信息,澳大利亚是全球最近物种灭绝率最高的国家之一。我们发现,专注于经济目标(例如渔业管理)的预测在时间上的预测时间明显更短,并且回答的管理问题范围更广,而专注于生物多样性保护的预测则更长。然后,我们评估了有关在澳大利亚管理七种主要陆地威胁的 484 项行动的有效性的科学文献,以确定近期预测为运营保护决策提供信息的机会。根据行动的不同,在管理之前、期间或之后,有 30%至 80%的威胁管理操作受到近期天气对结果的影响。疾病控制、物种转移/重新引入和栖息地恢复行动受到的影响最大,而物种死亡率增加和繁殖减少等负面影响比正影响更有可能发生。干旱或干燥条件以及降雨是最常报告的天气影响,这表明预测管理结果受低降雨量或过量降雨量影响的近期预测可能会带来最大的好处。在世界各地,许多地区像澳大利亚一样,正在变暖变干,或者经历更多的极端降雨事件。利用近期和季节性生态预测为保护决策提供信息对于利用不确定性和降低全球变化下威胁管理失败的风险将至关重要。