Michalek Anne K, Wong Samantha L, Brown-Johnson Cati G, Prochaska Judith J
Stanford Prevention Research Center, Department of Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA.
Evaluation Sciences Unit, Division of Primary Care and Population Health, Department of Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA.
Tob Use Insights. 2020 Jul 6;13:1179173X20921446. doi: 10.1177/1179173X20921446. eCollection 2020.
Research has documented higher smoking prevalence with unemployment and greater difficulty with gaining re-employment for those who smoke. Using photo elicitation methods, we sought to gain a deeper understanding of the connection between job-seeking and tobacco use.
Unemployed daily smokers (18 men, 1 woman) were recruited from the San Francisco Employment Development Department (EDD) and provided disposable cameras with 27 exposures and a list of 20 photo prompts related to job-seeking and tobacco. Study staff reviewed the photos with the participants and audio-recorded their narratives. The photos and narratives were coded for themes.
Of 363 photos, the most frequent photo imagery related to transportation (n = 56, 15.4%), work or education (n = 39, 10.7%), and littered cigarettes (n = 39, 10.7%). Narrated themes centered on motivators to quit smoking (255 mentions from 15 participants); people, places, and things associated with smoking (248 mentions, 16 participants); and motivators to secure work (157 mentions, 13 participants). The intersection of smoking and unemployment received 92 mentions from 11 participants, with 60 mentions (8 participants) identifying smoking as a barrier to re-employment.
Both motivators to quit and associated smoking cues were salient in the environments of job-seeking smokers. Struggles with quitting and perceptions that smoking is harming re-employment success suggest the potential for offering tobacco treatment in EDD settings. With permission, the photos and themes have been incorporated into a tobacco treatment intervention for job-seeking smokers.
研究表明,失业者的吸烟率较高,而且吸烟者重新就业的难度更大。我们采用照片启发法,试图更深入地了解求职与吸烟之间的联系。
从旧金山就业发展部(EDD)招募了失业的每日吸烟者(18名男性,1名女性),为他们提供了可拍摄27张照片的一次性相机以及一份与求职和吸烟相关的20个照片提示清单。研究人员与参与者一起查看照片,并对他们的叙述进行录音。对照片和叙述进行主题编码。
在363张照片中,最常见的照片意象与交通有关(n = 56,15.4%)、工作或教育有关(n = 39,10.7%)以及乱扔的香烟有关(n = 39,10.7%)。叙述的主题集中在戒烟的动机(15名参与者提及255次);与吸烟相关的人、地点和事物(16名参与者提及248次);以及获得工作的动机(13名参与者提及157次)。吸烟与失业的交叉点被11名参与者提及92次,其中60次(8名参与者)认为吸烟是重新就业的障碍。
对于正在求职的吸烟者来说,戒烟的动机和相关的吸烟线索在其所处环境中都很突出。在戒烟方面的挣扎以及认为吸烟会影响重新就业成功的看法表明,在就业发展部的环境中提供烟草治疗具有可能性。经许可,这些照片和主题已被纳入针对求职吸烟者的烟草治疗干预措施中。