Department of Physical Planning Development, Yusuf Maitama Sule University Kano, Kano, Nigeria.
Institute of Research and Development, Duy Tan University, Danang 550000, Vietnam.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2020 Nov;27(33):41524-41539. doi: 10.1007/s11356-020-09689-x. Epub 2020 Jul 20.
In recent decades, various conventional techniques have been formulated around the world to evaluate the overall water quality (WQ) at particular locations. In the present study, back propagation neural network (BPNN) and adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS), support vector regression (SVR), and one multilinear regression (MLR) are considered for the prediction of water quality index (WQI) at three stations, namely Nizamuddin, Palla, and Udi (Chambal), across the Yamuna River, India. The nonlinear ensemble technique was proposed using the neural network ensemble (NNE) approach to improve the performance accuracy of the single models. The observed WQ parameters were provided by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) including dissolved oxygen (DO), pH, biological oxygen demand (BOD), ammonia (NH), temperature (T), and WQI. The performance of the models was evaluated by various statistical indices. The obtained results indicated the feasibility of the developed data intelligence models for predicting the WQI at the three stations with the superior modelling results of the NNE. The results also showed that the minimum values for root mean square (RMS) varied between 0.1213 and 0.4107, 0.003 and 0.0367, and 0.002 and 0.0272 for Nizamuddin, Palla, and Udi (Chambal), respectively. ANFIS-M3, BPNN-M4, and BPNN-M3 improved the performance with regard to an absolute error by 41%, 4%, and 3%, over other models for Nizamuddin, Palla, and Udi (Chambal) stations, respectively. The predictive comparison demonstrated that NNE proved to be effective and can therefore serve as a reliable prediction approach. The inferences of this paper would be of interest to policymakers in terms of WQ for establishing sustainable management strategies of water resources.
在最近几十年中,世界各地已经制定了各种常规技术,以评估特定地点的整体水质 (WQ)。在本研究中,考虑了反向传播神经网络 (BPNN) 和自适应神经模糊推理系统 (ANFIS)、支持向量回归 (SVR) 和一个多元线性回归 (MLR),用于预测印度亚穆纳河上的三个站点——尼扎穆丁、帕拉和乌迪 (钱姆巴尔) 的水质指数 (WQI)。使用神经网络集成 (NNE) 方法提出了非线性集成技术,以提高单个模型的性能准确性。观察到的水质参数由中央污染控制委员会 (CPCB) 提供,包括溶解氧 (DO)、pH 值、生物需氧量 (BOD)、氨 (NH)、温度 (T) 和 WQI。通过各种统计指标评估模型的性能。结果表明,所开发的数据智能模型可用于预测三个站点的 WQI,NNE 的建模结果更优。结果还表明,尼扎穆丁、帕拉和乌迪 (钱姆巴尔) 站的 RMS 最小值分别在 0.1213 到 0.4107、0.003 到 0.0367 和 0.002 到 0.0272 之间变化。对于尼扎穆丁、帕拉和乌迪 (钱姆巴尔) 站,ANFIS-M3、BPNN-M4 和 BPNN-M3 分别将绝对误差提高了 41%、4%和 3%,从而提高了性能。预测比较表明,NNE 被证明是有效的,因此可以作为一种可靠的预测方法。本文的推论将引起决策者对水质量的关注,以便为水资源的可持续管理策略提供依据。