MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow College of Medical Veterinary and Life Sciences, Glasgow, UK
The Centre for the Development and Evaluation of Complex Public Health Interventions, Cardiff University, Cardiff, South Glamorgan, UK.
BMJ Open. 2020 Jul 20;10(7):e038965. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-038965.
Complex population health interventions that are effective in one context may not be effective elsewhere, and may even be harmful. As such, an intervention may require adaptation to ensure it fits with a new context. To date, there is no overarching guidance to help researchers to adapt and evaluate interventions in new contexts, and no criteria to support research funders or journals assess proposed or reported adaptations or evaluation. There is limited assistance for policy-makers and practitioners to decide if evidence-informed interventions are appropriate to their context, or if adaptation and further evaluation is needed. This Delphi exercise will contribute to the development of guidance for these communities to support the adaptation, implementation and/or re-evaluation of complex population health interventions in new contexts.
We will conduct a Delphi consensus exercise to gather expert opinion from researchers, research funders, journal editors and policy-makers. Expert opinion will be sought on: appropriate definitions and concepts, identifying key methodological considerations and establishing adaptations and processes to be undertaken during adaptation of complex population health interventions in new contexts.
Ethics approval for the Delphi exercise has been obtained from the University of Glasgow and and the RAND institutional research board. Dissemination of the results of this study will be through peer-reviewed publications, workshops at national and international conferences, and a summary of the guidance developed for key organisations and stakeholders.
在一种情况下有效的复杂人群健康干预措施在其他情况下可能无效,甚至可能有害。因此,干预措施可能需要进行调整,以确保其适应当地的新环境。迄今为止,尚无全面的指导意见帮助研究人员在新环境中调整和评估干预措施,也没有标准来支持研究资助者或期刊评估拟议或报告的调整或评估。决策者和从业人员在决定证据为基础的干预措施是否适应当地情况,或是否需要调整和进一步评估方面,所获得的帮助有限。这项德尔菲专家咨询研究将有助于为这些群体制定指导意见,以支持在新环境中调整、实施和/或重新评估复杂人群健康干预措施。
我们将进行一项德尔菲共识研究,以从研究人员、研究资助者、期刊编辑和决策者那里收集专家意见。将征求专家对以下方面的意见:适当的定义和概念、确定关键方法学考虑因素以及在新环境中调整复杂人群健康干预措施时应进行的调整和流程。
德尔菲研究的伦理批准已获得格拉斯哥大学和兰德机构研究委员会的批准。本研究结果将通过同行评议的出版物、在国家和国际会议上的研讨会以及为主要组织和利益攸关方制定的指导摘要进行传播。