Department of Psychology, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida, USA.
Department of Psychology, Roanoke College, Salem, Virginia, USA.
J Genet Psychol. 2020 Nov-Dec;181(6):427-442. doi: 10.1080/00221325.2020.1792401. Epub 2020 Jul 22.
We examined mean-level social goal development among peers during middle school, and self-esteem and narcissism as predictors of trait-like goal orientations across time. Survey data were collected on three occasions, in two middle schools in Finland (N = 384; 12-14 years; 53% girls). As expected, average increases in agentic-communal goals (reflecting prosocial self-assertion, or consideration of the self and others) and decreases in submissive-separate (isolation) goals were observed over time. Also, despite cross-sectional (concurrent) links from self-esteem to social status goals among peers reported in prior research, only narcissism was associated with increases in agentic (status) and agentic-separate (dominance) goals and decreases in goals of communal nature, whereas self-esteem was associated with increases in agentic-communal goals alone. Our findings align with and are discussed in the context of existing research on adolescent personal and social development. The findings provide among the first evidence for normative social goal development during middle school, and have implications for understanding self-esteem and narcissism in adolescent development: whereas narcissism is positively related to status and dominance goal development, self-esteem is only related to development of goals high in agentic communal orientation, reflecting consideration of the self as well as others.
我们考察了中学生同伴之间的社会目标发展的平均水平,以及自尊和自恋作为跨时间特质目标取向的预测指标。在芬兰的两所中学进行了三次调查(N=384;12-14 岁;53%为女生),收集了调查数据。正如预期的那样,随着时间的推移,亲社会自我主张(反映亲社会的自我主张,或考虑自我和他人)的代理-共通目标和分离-服从目标(孤立)呈平均增长。此外,尽管先前的研究报告了自尊与同伴社会地位目标之间存在横断面(同期)联系,但只有自恋与代理(地位)和代理-分离(支配)目标的增加以及具有共通性质的目标的减少有关,而自尊仅与代理-共通目标的增加有关。我们的研究结果与青少年个人和社会发展的现有研究相一致,并在其中进行了讨论。这些发现为中学期间的规范社会目标发展提供了首批证据之一,并对理解青少年发展中的自尊和自恋具有启示意义:虽然自恋与地位和支配目标的发展呈正相关,但自尊仅与具有高度代理-共通取向的目标的发展相关,反映了对自我和他人的考虑。