Virology Department, Centre Pasteur of Cameroon, Yaounde, Cameroon.
Evaluation and Research Unit, National AIDS Control Committee, Yaounde, Cameroon.
PLoS One. 2020 Jul 23;15(7):e0236267. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0236267. eCollection 2020.
Influenza virus accounts for majority of respiratory virus infections in Cameroon. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), influenza-like illnesses (ILI) are identified by a measured temperature of ≥38°C and cough, with onset within the past 10 days. Other symptoms could as well be observed however, none of these are specific to influenza alone. This study aimed to determine symptom based predictors of influenza virus infection in Cameroon. Individuals with ILI were recruited from 2009-2018 in sentinel sites of the influenza surveillance system in Cameroon according to the WHO case definition. Individual data collection forms accompanied each respiratory sample and contained clinical data. Samples were analyzed for influenza using the gold standard assay. Two statistical methods were compared to determine the most reliable clinical predictors of influenza virus activity in Cameroon: binomial logistic predictive model and random forest model. Analyses were performed in R version 3.5.2. A total of 11816 participants were recruited, of which, 24.0% were positive for influenza virus. Binomial logistic predictive model revealed that the presence of cough, rhinorrhoea, headache and myalgia are significant predictors of influenza positivity. The prediction model had a sensitivity of 75.6%, specificity of 46.6% and AUC of 66.7%. The random forest model categorized the reported symptoms according to their degree of importance in predicting influenza virus infection. Myalgia had a 2-fold higher value in predicting influenza virus infection compared to any other symptom followed by arthralgia, head ache, rhinorrhoea and sore throat. The model had a OOB error rate of 25.86%. Analysis showed that the random forest model had a better performance over the binomial regression model in predicting influenza infection. Rhinorrhoea, headache and myalgia were symptoms reported by both models as significant predictors of influenza infection in Cameroon. These symptoms could be used by clinicians in their decision to treat patients.
流感病毒是喀麦隆呼吸道病毒感染的主要病原体。世界卫生组织(WHO)表示,流感样疾病(ILI)的特征是体温≥38°C 伴有咳嗽,且发病于过去 10 天内。其他症状也可能存在,但这些都不是流感所特有的。本研究旨在确定喀麦隆流感病毒感染的基于症状的预测因子。根据 WHO 的病例定义,在喀麦隆流感监测系统的哨点从 2009 年至 2018 年招募患有 ILI 的个体。每个呼吸道样本都附有个人数据收集表,其中包含临床数据。使用金标准检测方法对样本进行流感分析。为了确定喀麦隆流感病毒活动的最可靠临床预测因子,比较了两种统计方法:二项逻辑预测模型和随机森林模型。分析在 R 版本 3.5.2 中进行。共招募了 11816 名参与者,其中 24.0%的人流感病毒检测呈阳性。二项逻辑预测模型显示,咳嗽、流涕、头痛和肌痛的存在是流感阳性的显著预测因子。该预测模型的灵敏度为 75.6%,特异性为 46.6%,AUC 为 66.7%。随机森林模型根据其对预测流感病毒感染的重要程度对报告的症状进行分类。肌痛对预测流感病毒感染的重要性是其他任何症状的两倍,其次是关节痛、头痛、流涕和咽痛。该模型的 OOB 错误率为 25.86%。分析表明,随机森林模型在预测流感感染方面的表现优于二项回归模型。流涕、头痛和肌痛是两种模型都报告的对流感感染有显著预测作用的症状。这些症状可被临床医生用于决定治疗患者。