Wilson Andrew, Bankart John, Regen Emma, Phelps Kay, Agarwal Shona, Johnson Mark, Raghavan Raghu, Sitaram Bina, Subramaniam Hari
Department of Health Sciences, University of Leicester, UK.
De Montfort University, UK.
BJPsych Open. 2020 Aug 3;6(5):e83. doi: 10.1192/bjo.2020.69.
The incidence of dementia in Black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) groups is increasing in the UK, with concern about underdiagnosis and late presentation.
By reviewing referrals to memory clinics from Leicester City we examined whether the following differed by ethnicity: the proportion with a diagnosis of dementia, type of dementia and severity at presentation.
We examined referrals between 2010 and 2017: all those whose ethnicity was recorded as Black (n = 131) and a random sample of 260 Asian and 259 White British referrals. Severity of dementia was assessed by record review. Odds ratios (ORs) were adjusted for general practice, age, gender and year of referral.
A diagnosis of dementia was recorded in 193 (74.5%) White British, 96 (73.3%) Black and 160 (61.5%) Asian referrals. Compared with Asians, White British had twice the adjusted odds of a dementia diagnosis (OR = 1.99 (1.23-3.22). Of those with dementia, Alzheimer's disease was more common in White British (57.0%) than in Asian (43.8%) and Black referrals (51.0%): adjusted OR White British versus Asian 1.76 (1.11-2.77). Of those with dementia, the proportion with moderate/severe disease was highest in White British (66.8%), compared with 61.9% in Asian and 45.8% in Black groups. The adjusted OR for the White versus Black groups was 2.03 (1.10-3.72), with no significant difference between Asian and White British groups.
Differences in confirmed dementia suggest general practitioners have a lower threshold for referral for possible dementia in some BAME groups. Unlike other centres, we found no evidence of greater severity at presentation in Asian and Black groups.
在英国,黑人、亚裔及少数族裔(BAME)群体中痴呆症的发病率正在上升,人们担心存在诊断不足和就诊过晚的情况。
通过回顾莱斯特市记忆诊所的转诊情况,我们研究了以下方面是否因种族而异:痴呆症诊断比例、痴呆症类型以及就诊时的严重程度。
我们研究了2010年至2017年期间的转诊情况:所有种族记录为黑人的患者(n = 131)以及260名亚裔和259名英国白人转诊患者的随机样本。通过病历审查评估痴呆症的严重程度。对全科医疗、年龄、性别和转诊年份进行了比值比(OR)调整。
在英国白人转诊患者中,193人(74.5%)被诊断为痴呆症,黑人患者中有96人(73.3%),亚裔患者中有160人(61.5%)。与亚裔相比,英国白人被诊断为痴呆症的调整后比值比是其两倍(OR = 1.99(1.23 - 3.22))。在患有痴呆症的患者中,阿尔茨海默病在英国白人中(57.0%)比在亚裔(43.8%)和黑人转诊患者中(51.0%)更为常见:英国白人相对于亚裔的调整后OR为1.76(1.11 - 2.77)。在患有痴呆症的患者中,中度/重度疾病比例在英国白人中最高(66.8%),亚裔为61.9%,黑人为45.8%。白人组与黑人组的调整后OR为2.03(1.10 - 3.72),亚裔和英国白人组之间无显著差异。
确诊痴呆症存在差异表明,全科医生对某些BAME群体中可能患有痴呆症的转诊阈值较低。与其他中心不同,我们没有发现亚裔和黑人群体在就诊时病情更严重的证据。