Thompson Jessica, White Simon, Chapman Stephen
School of Pharmacy and Bioengineering, Keele University, Keele, Newcastle ST5 5BG, UK.
Pharmacy (Basel). 2020 Aug 5;8(3):138. doi: 10.3390/pharmacy8030138.
Virtual patients are an active learning pedagogical tool that simulate clinical scenarios. There is an established disparity in pre-registration examination pass rates depending on whether individuals complete their training in a community or hospital pharmacy. This study aimed to evaluate virtual patient (VP) and non-interactive (NI) case studies, concerning knowledge, skill and confidence development of pre-registration pharmacist trainees. A quasi-experimental evaluation was conducted. Pre-registration pharmacists completed three VP or NI case studies. Each case study was associated with a pre-and post-knowledge quiz. Pre-registration trainees were invited to complete a questionnaire consisting of Likert ranking statements and open-ended questions on the case study features, usability and individual development. Both learning tools significantly improved trainees' knowledge on the topic areas (except for the NI group in case study 3). Although no significant differences in knowledge improvement were identified between the learning tools, trainees who used the VP reported the development of a wider knowledge base and skill set, an increase in confidence for practice and an opportunity to apply their learning. The sector in which pre-registration pharmacists were completing their training (community or hospital) had a significant impact on knowledge improvement in the three case studies. Future research evaluating VPs with pre-registration and qualified pharmacists should be conducted to explore their benefits and establish their effectiveness as learning tools.
虚拟患者是一种模拟临床场景的主动学习教学工具。根据个人是在社区药房还是医院药房完成培训,预注册考试通过率存在既定差异。本研究旨在评估虚拟患者(VP)和非交互式(NI)案例研究对预注册药剂师培训学员知识、技能和信心发展的影响。进行了一项准实验评估。预注册药剂师完成了三个VP或NI案例研究。每个案例研究都配有一个知识前后测问卷。邀请预注册学员完成一份问卷,问卷由李克特量表排序陈述以及关于案例研究特点、可用性和个人发展的开放式问题组成。两种学习工具都显著提高了学员在各主题领域的知识(案例研究3中的NI组除外)。虽然在学习工具之间未发现知识提升方面的显著差异,但使用VP的学员报告称,他们拓展了知识库和技能集,实践信心增强,并有机会应用所学知识。预注册药剂师完成培训的部门(社区或医院)对三个案例研究中的知识提升有显著影响。未来应开展评估预注册药剂师和合格药剂师使用虚拟患者情况的研究,以探索其益处并确定其作为学习工具的有效性。