Reubi David
Department of Social Science, Health & Medicine, King's College London, East Wing Building, Strand, London W2R 2LS, UK.
Biosocieties. 2018 Mar;13(1):81-102. doi: 10.1057/s41292-017-0055-2. Epub 2017 Jul 3.
Metrics have become all pervasive in global health today. Instead of highlighting their advantages or shortcomings, this article builds on Hacking's notion of historical ontology and explores their political, conceptual and material conditions of possibility. Drawing on research on the Bloomberg Initiative to Reduce Tobacco Use in Developing Countries, one of the largest international efforts to address the non-communicable disease epidemic in the global South, the article starts by introducing the notion of epidemiological reason - a thought style associated with modern epidemiology that undergirds the metrics permeating the global health field and which is made of a multiplicity of elements, from the ethical imperative to save lives to the social-scientific technique of the survey and the concept of global population. The article then goes on to explore the genealogy of this thought style, arguing that three epistemological ruptures have been critical to its development: the reconfiguration of power articulated around a biopolitics of population in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries; the twentieth-century shift in medical thought marked by the emergence of surveillance medicine and the idea of lifestyle; and the re-organisation of world health informed by globalisation theories at the start of the twenty-first century.
如今,指标在全球卫生领域已无处不在。本文并非着重强调其优点或缺点,而是基于哈金的历史本体论概念,探讨其在政治、概念和物质层面的可能性条件。文章以对彭博社减少发展中国家烟草使用倡议的研究为基础,该倡议是应对全球南方非传染性疾病流行的最大规模国际努力之一。文章开篇介绍了流行病学理性的概念,这是一种与现代流行病学相关的思维方式,支撑着渗透于全球卫生领域的各项指标,它由多种元素构成,从拯救生命的伦理要求到调查的社会科学技术以及全球人口概念。接着,文章探讨了这种思维方式的谱系,认为三次认识论上的断裂对其发展至关重要:18世纪和19世纪围绕人口生命政治所阐述的权力重新配置;20世纪以监测医学和生活方式观念的出现为标志的医学思想转变;以及21世纪初受全球化理论影响的世界卫生组织重组。